HOME > BUSINESS > HPCL to pay for gas explosion at customer premise after faulty repair

HPCL to pay for gas explosion at customer premise after faulty repair

hp-gasThe National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission has dismissed an appeal by Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd (HPCL) against an order by a lower body that imposed heavy damages on the company after faulty fixation of gas-tube led to an explosion at the premises of a customer.

HPCL and its gas agency were told to pay Rs 2.25 lakh in damages and Rs 25,000 in terms of compensation to V Venkateshwar Reddy, a resident of Kurnool in Andhra Pradesh, though both of them tried to shift the responsibility for the accident from themselves.

On 2.8.1996 in the morning, the Reddy lodged a complaint with Gowri Shankar Gas Agencies about leakage of gas from his pipe. The gas agency deputed a mechanic who cut the tube and fixed it again into the stove.

Next day, early morning at 2.00 a.m., there was an explosion in the kitchen which caused heavy damage to the house, creating cracks in the doors, walls, roof, bathroom etc.. The regulator had blown up to the roof breaking kitchen chimney, according to the complaint.

Both HPCL and the gas agency argued that the explosion was not caused by any fault of theirs.

The gas agency said the pipe was fixed at 10.30 a.m. and the explosion occured after almost 15 hours. So, it said, the fault could not have been in how the repair was carried out.

HPCL, on its part, said it had a pre-existing agreement with its gas agency that the gas agency’s actions were as ‘principal’ and not as an agent of HPCL. As a result, the agency shall be responsible in respect of all contracts or agreements entered into by him with the customers for sale of LPG and matters related therewith.

In view of this, HPCL argued that only the dealer is liable and responsible for its acts of omission or commission, if any, and, therefore, no liability could be fastened on Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd. for the same.

All the three levels of district courts dismissed the gas agency’s argument that said that the cause of the explosion has not been established.

For this, they relied on the testimony of C.S. Rajan, a professional Chemical Engineer.

He said the movement of the persons during the day time with open windows and the closer of the movements and the windows closing during the night time were the reason for the belated explosion due to any ignitions of the Refrigerator switches etc.

“The said probability being not dis-credit by the other side with any contra material, it remains not only convincing but also a more probable cause,” the courts noted.

HPCL too was not let off by the consumer courts. They noted that HPCL was the company that supplied the cylinder. And that there was a chance that the leakage was from the cylinder. As a result, HPCL cannot escape liability.

“The circumstantial evidence clearly goes to show that the explosion caused due to gas leakage and Ex. A8 clearly states that Opposite Party No. 1 (gas agency) with the help of Senior Sales Officer, H.P. Corporation destroyed the material evidence to shirk from their responsibility,” the Andhra Pradesh state consumer forum noted.

“Opposite Parties 1 & 2 (agency and HPCL) also failed to establish that the explosion occurred due to the reasons other than the gas leakage. According to the Survey conducted by Bharat Petroleum Corporation that 50% of cooking gas related accidents occurs because of leakages from tube. In view of the aforementioned reasons, we are inclined to accept that the explosion occurred due to gas leakage and caused extensive damage to the house of the complainant in the light of technical Material Safety Data Sheet issued by Bharat Petroleum which supports the contention of the complainant.”

The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission, comprising Justice VB Gupta and Suresh Chandra, exonerated New India Insurance Co Ltd — which was the insurer to the gas agency — from having to pay for the accident.

Follow ULTRA.news
Larsen & Toubro wins Rs 1,600 cr order from HPCL Construction major Larsen & Toubro said its hydrocarbon subsidiary won an order worth over Rs 1,600 cr from Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd for its Visakhapatnam Refinery.The project involves Engineering, Procurement, Construction and Commissioning of 3 million tonne...
RERA sales freeze drags down DLF Q2 profit by 94%, sales restarted Real estate major DLF reported a sharp decline in its revenue and profit for the July-September quarter after it stopped taking new bookings due to the implementation of RERA in May.The company's net profit fell by 94% to Rs 12.57 cr in July-September quarter from Rs 204.60 ...
Reliance, Essar triple petrol outlets in 2 yr, continue to expand fast – India Ratings Private players such as Reliance Industries and Essar -- owned by Russia's Rosneft -- have tripled the number of petrol and diesel outlets in India in the last two years, and could double their market share by implementing their ongoing expansion plans, India Ratings said.Fro...
HPCL appoints bankers for Rs 6,000 cr FCCB issue Hindustan Petroleum Corp Ltd said it had appointed banking intermediaries for organizing investor meetings in the run up to raising Rs 6,000 cr ($930 mln) by selling foreign-currency denominated bonds.The bonds will be non-convertible, and will be issued if the meetings disco...
Complaints against telcos drop sharply as 4G takes off No of complaints against telcos in last three years. 2017 nos are annualizedComplaints against all telecom providers except Bharti Airtel dropped in 2016, possibly in reaction to the emergence of new operator Reliance Jio and the explosion of 4G data capacity.The total n...
DIESEL PRICE CUT: After Airtel & Idea, Reliance to target IOCL, HPCL, BPCL? Reliance Industries, which started giving a discount of Re 1 on every liter of diesel sold through its pumps in January, has now started advertising the offer in Kerala. The discount was first noticed in January in North and West Indian towns.The move was, at the time, no...
India Oil, BPCL, HPCL merger will reduce wastage of resources- Fitch A proposed merger of Indian Oil Corp, Hindustan Petroleum Corp and Bharat Petroleum Corp will reduce inefficiencies across the sector and result in enormous savings, ratings agency Fitch said.It would also create an entity that is better placed to compete globally for resourc...
Govt of India starts crack down on low-quality medicine makers The government of India has started conducting inspections at drug manufacturing units across the country to prevent the production of low-quality drugs and medicines in India.Typically, inspections are conducted by state authorities, while central agencies largely confin...
HPCL, Aditya Birla Fashion to start accepting ICICI Bank’s UPI payments ICICI Bank said it has tied up with Hindustan Petroleum Corporation Ltd and Aditya Birla Fashion and Retail Limited to offer UPI based payments their retail outlets.The bank also said it has become the first in India to have 1 lakh registered virtual payment addresses under t...
Gurgaon resident seeks Rs 1.25 cr damages from PepsiCo in ‘Slice’ complaint The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, the apex consumer court in India, has dismissed a petition by Gurgaon-resident Gaurav Garg seeking a compensation of Rs 1.25 cr from PepsiCo India and its bottling partner after allegedly falling ill as a result of consuming a bottl...
TATA AIG gets into buffalo trouble for dishonoring animal insurance Tata AIG General Insurance Co, one of India's top insurers, has been pulled up by the country's top consumer court after the company claimed that it did not insure a buffalo as claimed by a farmer, and that someone had cheated the farmer by forging documents."It is a sad sto...
India Post cannot be prosecuted for lost parcels – Consumer Commission The National Consumer Rights Redressal Commission, India's top consumer court, has reversed orders by lower foras that had awarded damages in lieu of a registered post that was lost in transit by India Post.Presiding member Justice JM Malik set aside the orders of district a...
Air India wins case against passenger ejected for faulty visa The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, the apex body of consumer courts in India, cancelled the compensation of over Rs 1.3 lakhs awarded to a student who had been ejected by Air India over transit visa problems.The student, daughter of Sushil Kumar of Amritsar, had ...
Govt writes to district forums not to reject telecom complaints The government of India, through Ministry of Consumer Affairs, has written to all consumer disputes redressal bodies asking them not to reject consumer complaints against telecom operators as many of them have been doing for years.Consumer forums, including state-level bodies...
MNP fumble: Vodafone, Airtel told to compensate Kolkata resident Vodafone and Bharti Airtel have been told to compensate a customer after Vodafone disconnected a customer who ported from Airtel saying that the customer did not pay Airtel's bills. The North 24 Parganas district consumer forum found that Bharti Airtel guilty of issuing 'vague bi...
Builder argues real estate investment not covered under consumer law Giving relief to a builder, the National Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum has asked the Punjab State Consumer Disputes Forum to determine whether someone who buys a real estate property without the intention of living in it can be given protection under consumer laws.In a ca...
Karbonn Mobile to compensate after it runs out of stock for warranty replacement Karbonn Mobile has been told to pay Rs 5,000 as compensation and litigation expenses after the company said it no longer had a new handset to give to a customer whose handset stopped working properly during warranty time.The company was also told by the District Consumer ...
Ghaziabad consumer forum dismisses case against Bharti Airtel despite DoT clarification Despite repeated clarifications from the Central Government, a district consumer forum has dismissed a consumer complaint against Bharti Airtel Ltd and asked the consumer to set up arbitration against the telecom company to resolve a billing dispute of Rs 347.Arbitration pane...
Idea Cellular fined Rs 25,000 for deactivating SIM Idea Cellular Ltd, India's third biggest mobile company, has been fined Rs 25,000 for deactivating a SIM.Idea claimed that the connection was deactivated due to disuse, while the consumer, Anand Krishnan of Kasargod in Kerala, claimed that the number was in use regularly....
Bharti Airtel fined Rs 5 lakh for insensitive customer service A New Delhi consumer forum has imposed a fine of Rs 5 lakh on Bharti Airtel Ltd after the company continued to seek dues from a person even after the bill was paid.In a complaint by IT professional Jasmeet Singh Puri, the forum also expressed its consternation at the "lackada...