HOME > SOCIETY > India’s drone project halted by Green Tribunal

India’s drone project halted by Green Tribunal

India’s National Green Tribunal has stopped construction activity at its first drone research and manufacturing facility in Karnataka for lack of forest clearance.

Justice Mr. M. Chockalingam (Judicial Member) and Prof. Dr. R. Nagendran (Expert Member) constituting the National Green Tribunal (Southern Zone Bench), issued a direction on 14th February 2014 halting all construction in the ecologically sensitive Amrut Mahal Kaval grassland ecosystems in Challakere Taluk, Chitradurga district, Karnataka.

The direction was issued in response to complaints raised by NGOs including Amritmahal Kaval Hitarakshana Horata Samithi and Environment Support Group. They alleged that various agencies that had been allocated lands for their projects in the Kaval had commenced construction without securing permission from the Karnataka Forest Department and Union Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF) for diversion of forest land to non-forest purpose based on ecological assessments.

Defence Research Development Organisation (DRDO) which is proposing construction of a massive weaponised drone testing and manufacture project, had already commenced extensive construction operations. In particular referring to this, the Tribunal ordered:

“The counsel for the DRDO on instructions from the official, who is present, would submit that the construction activities are continuing. It is pertinent to point out that whether the construction activities now being carried out by DRDO lies in the reserve forest or not is the subject matter to be decided by the Tribunal. In view of the factual position and circumstances, it would be fit and proper to issue a direction to DRDO to stop further construction until further orders of the Tribunal and accordingly a direction is issued to DRDO to stop construction activities in the subject matter land until further orders.”

Besides DRDO other agencies allotted these grassland ecosystems that form habitat for critically endangered Great Indian Bustard and Lesser Florican, highly threatened Black Buck, and support livelihoods of thousands of pastoral communities include Bhabha Atomic Research Centre (BARC – nuclear fuel enrichment), Indian Institute of Science (IISc – building a synchrotron), Indian Space Research Organisation (ISRO – space applications), Sagitaur (private company to build a solar pond), Karnataka Housing Board (KHB – construction of villas), etc.

Several of these agencies have begun project activities by building high security walls, undertaken massive project construction and also blocked access of local communities to the Kavals, the petitioners said.

The 10,000 acres of Amrithmahal Kavals found here form the last contiguous stretch of grasslands left in Karnataka state. At the time of independence, the State had over 450,000 acres of Kavals, and only 30,000 acres are now left. Such systematic and reckless diversion of ecological commons has caused agony to thousands of pastoral and farming families dependent on these Kavals for their livelihoods,  the NGOs said.

Challenging this diversion before the National Green Tribunal (Southern Zone), the Petitioners have said that the entire exercise was illegal as no assessment of the ecological and social impacts was ever conducted, no proper assessment was carried out to assess the appropriateness of siting such dangerous and highly sensitive facilities all in one location, nor was there any compliance with environmental protection, pollution control and land use planning regulations. Besides, they said, the entire exercise was undertaken with extraordinary secrecy, including by keeping elected bodies and representatives out of the decision making process.

While the implications of these decisions were being argued before the Tribunal, the Karnataka State Pollution Control Board accorded Consent for Establishment to the DRDO and Sagitaur projects during September 2013. However, the consent was conditional to the fact that “in case the area proposed for the purpose of the project is found to be forest area, necessary forest clearance shall have to be obtained,” the NGOs argued.

In October 2013, MoEF filed its statement before the Tribunal stating that Amrit Mahal Kavals constitute forest areas as per the Karnataka Forest Act, 1961, Forest Conservation Act, 1980 and the orders of the Hon’ble Supreme Court in the Godavarman case (WP Civil 202/1995). The Ministry specifically said that “the status of 9,473 acres of land as “forest” or “non-forest” is to be decided through joint inspection by the State Forest Department and Regional Office of the Ministry, as per guidelines issued by the Supreme Court in Lafarge Judgment and interpretation of the Karnataka Forest Act and Rules framed thereunder.” Rather than immediately halt any construction activities, DRDO, for instance, continued massive building work which they refused to stop despite local protests and filing of police complaints,  it was alleged.

As these activities are in breach of conditions imposed in the Consent for Establishment issued by the Karnataka State Pollution Control Board, the regulatory agency has been moved to withdraw the consent and initiate appropriate action against the violators, the petitioners said.

Follow ULTRA.news
Chinese soldiers start working with Pak army on Gujarat, Rajasthan border – BSF A report by the Border Security Force has flagged what it called increasing presence of Chinese military personnel on India's border with Pakistan.While the presence of Chinese troop in the Gilgit Baltistan region near the trijunction of the three countries was already known...
Tata Power, Israeli partner get sonar contract from Indian Navy Tata Power said its Strategic Engineering Division, along with partner DSIT Solutions Ltd, received a contract to supply Portable Diver Detection Sonar (PDDS) to the Indian Navy.The deal is one of the the largest in the world for such systems, it said.The detection syste...
India to see 6 GW of wind power auctioned in 5 months Inox Wind Limited, the most aggressive player in bidding for new wind power projects, said it expects almost 6 GW of new wind power projects to be auctioned in India over the next five months.In comparison, the country added 5.4 GW of wind power capacity on the ground in the...
CNG price increased by 95 paise per kg in Delhi, Rs 1.26 in NCR Indraprastha Gas Ltd, which sells CNG to the National Capital Region, said it has raised the price of CNG by 95 paise per kg in Delhi and by Rs 1.26 per kg in the consumer price of CNG in Noida, Greater Noida and Ghaziabad.In Rewari, the price will be increased by Rs 1 per kg...
Infosys included in Dow Jones Sustainability Index Infosys said it has been inducted into the Dow Jones Sustainability Indices (DJSI) and is now part of two of the indices -- DJSI World and DJSI Emerging Markets.The indices measure the economic, environmental and social performance of companies and are based on the companie...
South India still water-stressed despite decent monsoon Despite a decent monsoon season, water levels at storage facilities in India continues to be below those of last year as well as the 10-year average.Of particular concern is the situation in South India, only 39% of the total capacity of the reservoirs has been filled so far...
Post Doklam, India and Japan agree to increase defence cooperation India and Japan have agreed to increase defence cooperation, particularly in terms of providing mutual training as well as in sharing technology.India's outgoing defence minister Arun Jaitley reached several agreements with his Japanese counterpart in this matter, days after ...
Adani, Saab tie-up; to pitch Gripen jets to India Defence and security company Saab, maker of Gripen jets, has tied up with India's Adani Group for aerospace and defence production in India."The intended collaboration would encompass design, development and production of Gripen for India and other high-tech products of nat...
Tata Power to set up electric vehicle charging stations in Mumbai Tata Power announced its plan to set up electric vehicle charging stations across Mumbai, and has set up the first one at its compound in Vikhroli."These chargers would facilitate electric car users to charge their cars (Battery Electric Vehicles such as the Mahindra e2O, Nis...
India draws closer to US under Modi, to restart ‘COPE INDIA’ The Narendra Modi-led National Democratic Alliance government of India is ramping up defense cooperation with the United States, and will restart COPE INDIA, a mock combat exercise between the US and Indian Air Force.COPE INDIA was first conducted in 2004, and subsequently in...
Tejas continues to face delivery delays Hindustan Aeronautics Ltd or HAL continues to run well behind schedule in delivering India's first indigenous jet fighter, Tejas Mark I.The government-controlled company was supposed to have delivered four Tejas Mark I aircraft by March 2016, and a total of 12 by March 2017, ...
How India’s enemies are using fake news to wage information war In the old days, wars were fought using armies standing face to face, such as in the first world war. Then came the aeroplanes and the jets, which allowed wars to be fought in the air, and far inland from the front lines, as was seen in the second world war.A fake news websi...
India achieves only 14% of rooftop solar power target Even as India more or less sticks to the target on adding large solar farms under its ambitious Solar Mission project, the other leg of the plan -- rooftop solar -- remains woefully behind target.Under the solar mission, India is supposed to have put in 5,000 megawatt of sola...
Reliance Defence Engg launches patrol ships for Indian Navy Reliance Defence and Engineering, controlled by Reliance Infrastructure, said it 'launched' the first two of its five patrol vessels being built for the Indian Navy at its shipyard in Pipavav, Gujarat.The ships are being constructed under the "P-21" project.The Company i...
Pakistan Army protests cross-border attacks by India Pakistan's Director General of Military Operations protested Indian attacks on the Line of Control in Kashmir in a meeting with his Indian counterpart.According to a statement released by the Indian side, Pakistan complained that Indian Army had killed four Pakistani soldiers...
Surya introduces 32-watt full-size ceiling fan with BLDC technology Surya Roshni, one of India's oldest electrical brands, said it launched what could be India's most power efficient full-size ceiling fan -- the SS-32.The fan belongs to the new breed of brushless or BLDC fans that use an electronic circuit to convert alternating current into ...
Reliance Infra defence unit inks one more deal to help with Rafale work Reliance Defence, the defence-focused subsidiary of Reliance Infrastructure, said it entered into yet another agreement with an overseas company. This time, the company said it tied up with Daher Aerospace, France, a supplier of integrated systems for aeroplanes.Daher makes ...
Anil Ambani Group ties up with Thales for Rafale contracts Reliance Defence, the defence manufacturing arm of the Anil Ambani group, said it will form a joint venture in India with global defence manufacturer Thales to carry out some contracts related to the Rafale jet deal.The Indian company will hold 51% of the equity while the fo...
L&T wins largest ever private sector defence order, to supply K9 VAJRA-T guns Engineering conglomerate Larsen & Toubro entered into a contract with the Ministry of Defence, Government of India to supply of 100 units of 155mm, 52 calibre Tracked Self-Propelled Gun systems to the Indian Army.The contract valued at about ₹ 4500 crore, is the largest o...
TCS opens drone facility in the US Tata Consultancy Services said it has opened its first research lab for drones in the US at its Seven Hills Park Innovation Center located in Cincinnati, Ohio.The lab will address the rapidly expanding demand for unmanned aerial vehicles and business Solutions across industr...