HOME > BUSINESS > Dead insects in Fanta; Hindustan Coca-Cola to pay

Dead insects in Fanta; Hindustan Coca-Cola to pay

The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission of India has dismissed an appeal by Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages, a part of The Coca-Cola Company’s Bottling Investments Group, against an order by a lower court awarding compensation to customer who found dead insects floating inside a Fanta bottle.

Asking for relief, Hindustan Coca-Cola said there was no proof that the Fanta bottle was actually manufactured by them. It argued that the bottle was spurious.

“They contended that there is no evidence that the said bottle was actually manufactured by them,” said NCDRC, the country’s top consumer court, paraphrasing the argument. “They (Hindustan Coca-Cola and distributors) further contended that the product is spurious and that their Bottling Plant is of latest technology with high standard of hygiene and there is no question of any insect entering into the bottle. The bottles are sold after conducting a number of tests.”

However, the Court comprising Justic JM Malik and Dr SM Kantikar, pointed out that the company did not provide any evidence that the bottle was indeed spurious, and did not give a batch sample to the laboratory that was testing the bottle for authenticity.

“The visual examination of bottle shows one large Insect (approximately sized 10mm) floating on top of the bottle; two small insects and several insects Body parts are suspended in the fluid,” Choksi Laboratories Ltd said in its report.

A laboratory report was also sought on the authenticity of the bottle. In the report, the laboratory said that some of the features of the bottle in question were different from a Fanta bottle that was purchased from the market. However, to be sure, the laboratory would need bottle samples from the batch code printed on the bottle.

“It is, therefore, indeterminable that the bottle is indeed the same as that of the manufacturer or not unless a control sample is provided by the manufacturer from the same batch,” it said.

The court faulted Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages for not cooperating with the laboratory investigation and upheld the compensation of Rs 10,000 in favor of original complainant Purushottam Gaur of Indore.

The “onus of proof shifts on to the opposite parties (Hindustan Coca-Cola and distributors) after the receipt of the report from the Laboratory,” NCDRC said in its final order.

“They did not raise any objection. They did not try to help the Laboratory personnel. They did not even answer the questions posed by the Incharge of the Laboratory and did not provide any assistance to the Laboratory personnel. Mere saying that OP4 [opposite party 4, the shopkeeper] has no connection with them, is not enough. They should have made an enquiry as to why this bottle was sold by OP4. OP4 could have given the answer from where he had purchased this bottle. No efforts were made by OPs 1 to 3 (Hindustan Coca-Cola and distributors) regarding the origin of that bottle. Prima facie, it appears that this bottle belongs to OPs 1 to 3.

“They have failed to rebut the evidence against them. They must find out as to who is copying their bottle. The control sample was never provided by the OPs to the Laboratory Incharge. The manufacturer could not help as to where the bottle had been opened and re-packed with a new cap. The OPs could have appointed their own Expert to find out, whether, the bottle in question, belonged to them or not?.

“The question is, who could manufacture the bottles on behalf of OPs 1 to 3. Such like incidences, come to light, immediately. The petitioner is conspicuously silent about the same. The silence on their part is pernicious. The case against OPs 1 to3 stands proved. The revision petition (by Hindustan Coca-Cola and distributors), being without merit, is hereby dismissed,” the Court ordered.

Follow ULTRA.news
Bharti Airtel denies violating Aadhaar norms Bharti Airtel today said it has not violated any norms set down by the UID Authority of India for the use of Aadhaar verification.Responding to a notice from the stock exchanges, the company confirmed having received notices from the UID Authority on alleged violations of no...
Dr Reddy’s gets served with class action lawsuit Pharma major Dr Reddy's Laboratories said it has been served with a class action lawsuit, originally announced in August, related to public disclosures made about regulatory action against the company."Further to our intimation dated August 28, 2017 with regard to US Securit...
RCom sends legal notice to rivals for spreading rumors Anil Ambani Group's Reliance Communication said it has sent 'cease and desist' notices to its rivals trying to win over its enterprise customers by creating fear about the company shutting down.The development comes in the wake of announcements by the company that it was gra...
RERA sales freeze drags down DLF Q2 profit by 94%, sales restarted Real estate major DLF reported a sharp decline in its revenue and profit for the July-September quarter after it stopped taking new bookings due to the implementation of RERA in May.The company's net profit fell by 94% to Rs 12.57 cr in July-September quarter from Rs 204.60 ...
HCL Infosystems gets tax notice for Rs 312 cr plus penalties HCL Infosystems, the India-focused IT arm of HCL Group, said it received a tax demand of Rs 312.34 cr plus interest and an amount equal to the interest amount as penalty.The company, which is already struggling with losses, did not specify the amount of interest involved or ...
LIC withdraws insolvency case against DB Realty Life Insurance Corporation of India, the single biggest shareholder in many listed companies in India, has withdrawn its insolvency case against DB Realty Ltd, the real estate developer said.The two companies have executed a debt settlement agreement on Oct 16, DB Realty sai...
Dr Reddy’s hit by class action suit on “misleading statements” on FDA action Pharma giant Dr Reddy's Labs today said that a class action lawsuit has been filed against it on behalf of shareholders, alleging that the company misled investors causing them to lose money on their investments."The lawsuit alleges that the company made materially false and...
Kapil Mishra to file FIR against Arvind Kejriwal Estranged Aam Aadmi Party leader Kapil Mishra said he will file a police complaint against Arvind Kejriwal today.The rebel AAP leader has accused the party supremo of taking bribes and acting like a dictator within the party."It is with a heavy heart that I am doing this,...
Supreme Court refuses to change decision in Saumya murder case GovindaswamyThe Supreme Court has dismissed a curative petition filed by the Kerala Government against its decision finding the main accused not guilty in the prominent Saumya rape and murder case of Kerala.The case, analogous to the Nirbhaya episode of Delhi, had shocke...
All liquor shops in Tamil Nadu to remain shut for 3 months The Madras High Court has asked the government of Tamil Nadu not to open any liquor shops for three months after complaints that it did not comply with the Supreme Court order on relocating roadside liquor shops.Unlike in most states in India, alchohol shops in Tamil Nadu are...
Complaints against telcos drop sharply as 4G takes off No of complaints against telcos in last three years. 2017 nos are annualizedComplaints against all telecom providers except Bharti Airtel dropped in 2016, possibly in reaction to the emergence of new operator Reliance Jio and the explosion of 4G data capacity.The total n...
Nokia files more patent infringement suits against Apple Nokia has filed further complaints alleging that Apple products infringe a number of Nokia patents, expanding its litigation originally announced on December 21. Across actions in 11 countries, there are now 40 patents in suit, which cover technologies such as display, us...
Govt of India starts crack down on low-quality medicine makers The government of India has started conducting inspections at drug manufacturing units across the country to prevent the production of low-quality drugs and medicines in India.Typically, inspections are conducted by state authorities, while central agencies largely confin...
Supreme Court bans liquor sales along national and state highways The Supreme Court of India has banned the sale of liquor along highways in India.It has ordered that all the licenses of liquor shops in and around the national and state highways in all the states should be closed when their licenses expire.During the trial, the cour...
Welspun says ‘Egyptian Cotton’ related US lawsuits not yet material Welspun said it believed that two complaints against the company for allegedly using non-Egyptian cotton may or may not be allowed to proceed as class action lawsuits, and are therefore not yet 'material'.The company was responding to a question by the stock exchanges of Indi...
Wipro says ESIC withholds dues under contract IT provider Wipro Ltd said Indian government's Employees' State Insurance Corporation has withheld payments due to it after the completion of a project, and it will take legal action to recover the amount.The seven-year contract, named Project Panchdeep, was completed on June...
ACC, Ambuja to challenge Competition Commission order ACC Ltd and Ambuja Cements said they will challenge the fine imposed by the Competition Commission of India yesterday, and that a similar order passed by the CCI four years ago had been set aside by the Competition Appellate Tribunal in December last year."We await receip...
Finance Ministry DID NOT reject Tata arbitration payment – DoCoMo Japanese telecom major DoCoMo said it was not aware of any new decision by the finance ministry on the issue of payment of arbitration amount by Tata Sons.A report by the Press Trust of India yesterday claimed that the Finance Ministry had rejected a proposal by the Reserve B...
DoCoMo reiterates Tata Sons must pay $1.17 bln DoCoMo, the Japan-based telecom group and a partner of Tata Sons in their telecom venture in India, said there are no impediments for Tata Sons to pay the penalty awarded by the London Court of International Arbitration.DoCoMo said Tata Sons should not use a recent decision b...
Gurgaon resident seeks Rs 1.25 cr damages from PepsiCo in ‘Slice’ complaint The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Forum, the apex consumer court in India, has dismissed a petition by Gurgaon-resident Gaurav Garg seeking a compensation of Rs 1.25 cr from PepsiCo India and its bottling partner after allegedly falling ill as a result of consuming a bottl...