HOME > BUSINESS > Modi Gov should abolish the APMC Act – Crisil

Modi Gov should abolish the APMC Act – Crisil

Among the sectors crying out for reform under the new Narendra Modi government is agriculture and food production. Crisil, arguably India’s biggest credit rating and economy research house, has called for the new government to abolish the Agricultural Produce Market Committee Act or APMC to curb high food price inflation.

food-inflation

The APMC Act prohibits farmers from selling their produce outside a government monitored mechanism of mandis or markets. The idea, initially, was to ensure that the government had a level of control over the prices at which the vegetables and fruits were being sold, and direct buyers, like companies, did not exploit farmers.

However, in the last few decades, an elaborate network of middlemen and traders have sprung up in the mandis, who often collude to drive down prices that the farmers are able to get for their crops. The crops have to be brought physically to the mandi to be sold, and farmers are often in no position to take back the produce if they find the prices low.

As farmers are not allowed to sell directly to companies, and have to go through APMC mandis, they are not able to get a higher price even as the price of fruits and vegetables have doubled in the last three years.

“The APMC Act should be abolished altogether. Specifically, delisting of fruits and vegetables from the APMC can help lower prices. This will allow markets in agricultural products to develop. Farmers will get to trade freely with private buyers, the role of middlemen will be reduced and it will also incentivise private players to invest in back-end facilities,” Crisil Research said.

Many super-market chains, such as Bharti and Walmart, have sought exemption from APMC Act to be allowed to enter into purchase transactions directly with the farmers. In the states where this has been allowed to a small degree, the companies often provide technical help to the farmers to ensure a bumper crop. An abolition of the APMC Act would also enable companies to provide money in advance to farmers and enter into future transactions at a specified price with them. This would ensure that farmers would get a predetermined price irrespective of fluctuations in market rates, and that companies would get their raw materials at a fixed prices, instead of being dependent on market rates.

It would also open the way for more effective crop insurance, as companies are often ready to take the risk of crop damage if they are given suitable financial incentive for doing so in the form of a steady supply of raw material.

“Some progress on reforming the APMC act has begun with notifications by states to delist fruits and vegetables from the Act. But these are unlikely to have a considerable impact on price till the major grower-states — Punjab, Maharashtra and Uttar Pradesh — also step up to the plate,” Crisil said.

The current situation, in which middle men fleece the farmers, has assured India of high rates of fruit and vegetable price inflation.

“The Agricultural Produce Market Committee Act, put in place to help farmers sell their produce in the market, has actually left them vulnerable to price manipulation by traders and agents. Commission agents help farmers sell their produce to traders and the government. They are driven by the incentive to maximise the number of transactions they undertake rather than getting the highest price for the farmer. In addition, they can collude and manipulate prices.

“The produce typically goes through 3-4 layers of middlemen before reaching the consumer, with each layer adding a mark-up leading to the final price. The higher the number of middlemen, the lower is the price the farmers get. In addition, the government mandis where traders buy the produce do not have proper storage or infrastructure facilities, leading to wastage. Thus, layers of intermediaries and wastage
lead to an increase in inflation.”

Walmart has been lobbying with the government to be allowed to strike deals directly with farmers and to buy produce in advance. Walmart is ready, for example, to install cold storage facilities if it is able to source fruits and vegetables with more certainty.

Other factors have also contributed to high price inflation, Crisil said.

“The increase in minimum support price (MSP) over the years has provided a floor for food grain prices, making them rigid on the downside. For example, the MSP for paddy has more than doubled since 2004-05 to 2013-14, resulting in sticky inflation. High MSPs have also kept the cropping pattern biased towards food grains like rice and wheat, and have led to excessive production. But the government’s inability to intervene and release excess food stocks on time has allowed prices to hold firm at higher levels. Inflation has remained close to 9% even as the government’s stocks of rice, wheat and coarse cereals have more than tripled since 2008.”

Similarly, a demand-supply mismatch in proteins — pulses and non-vegetarian foods, also contributed. “Loose fiscal policy, rising demand for high– value food items and substantial increase in wages – especially rural wages, as a spillover the rural employment guarantee scheme – have translated into higher demand for proteins. This has raised the prices of items such as milk & milk products, egg, fish and meat as supply falls short of demand. The production of milk and eggs has risen only 3-4% a year, compounded annually, during 2009-10 to 2012-13, while inflation in this category has risen 14-15% a year.”

Another reason is the shift to faster-growing and higher-value non-food crops. “The pattern of land use has tilted in favour of these crops with growth in the area under non-food grains rising considerably (2.9% average growth in 2005-13 vis-à-Vis 0.1% in the previous decade).”

“The land cultivated is still majorly under cereals, particularly in Punjab, because of ever-rising minimum support prices. That’s why there is excess stock of rice and wheat despite only a marginal increase in productivity.

“Additionally, although fertiliser usage has gone up, it has become more unbalanced. The ideal NPK ratio is 4:2:1 but the current level is 6.7:3:1 (2012-13). The subsidy on nitrogenous fertiliser has led to excessive use of urea and distorted the nutrient balance in the soil. Clearly, urea subsidy needs to go if long-term damage is to be avoided.”

Wastage has been another problem.

“The value of fruits and vegetable wastage stood at Rs 700 billion in 2010-11 and Rs 630 billion in 2009-10 – or a third of the entire production… A good two-thirds of the wastage was found avoidable.”

In the medium term, the government needs to focus on improving procurement, storage, marketing and logistics, it added. “Last fiscal, for every Rs 100 worth of wheat and rice bought, the government incurred an additional cost of Rs 51 and Rs 66, respectively, towards procurement costs (including state taxes), and storage and distribution.”

Follow ULTRA.news
Expecting waivers, farmers stop paying back bank loans? The write-off of farm loans in Uttar Pradesh and Maharashtra seems to be encouraging farmers in other states to stop paying back their farm loans to make sure that they will get the benefits of any farm loan waiver program in their state. This has led to a sharp increase in farm ...
IT companies using illegal tactics to force workers to resign: FITE The Forum for IT Employees, arguably the IT workers rights organization with the largest number of well-wishers and supporters, accused IT companies of using illegal and unethical means to force their workers to submit their resignations.In a meeting with Maharashtra Chief Mi...
Demonetization took India forward by 3 years – SBI The demonetization of currency notes late last year has doubled the number of card transactions and helped push India's payment digitisation by three years, State Bank of India said in a note."Even after seven months post demonetization, the transaction value is quite large ...
Farm loan wavers can impact India’s financial profile – Fitch Ratings agency Fitch said the string of farm loan waivers announced by various Indian states could impact the financial profile of the country as a whole.The agency, however, did not directly say that the moves could lead to a downgrade in India's credit rating, which would i...
Indian IT industry facing layoffs as conditions worsen, warns Assocham Trump unveiled his 'Buy American, Hire American' program yesterdayIndian IT companies are bound to see "some laying off" of their work force back home due to various negative forces impacting the industry, Assocham -- an association of various industries -- warned."With ...
Rs 1.7 lakh cr deposited via demonetization may not be withdrawn – SBI Monthly cash withdrawals for all banks | source:SBI ResearchThe Indian banking system is likely to get a permanent liquidity boost of Rs 1.7 lakh cr due to the demonetization of high-denomination bank notes, State Bank of India chief economic adviser said in a note to bank c...
After missing twice, India comfortably meets power sector targets for 12th five-year plan After missing its targets by wide margins in the previous two five-year plans, India is all set to comfortably meet or exceed all its power sector targets for the 12th five-year plan that ends this month.Five-year plans, borrowed from the Soviet Union, are a legacy of Nehruvi...
Center imposes stock-holding limits on sugar Faced with the prospect of lower-than-expected production of sugar in the ongoing season due to drought, the government has imposed stock curbs on dealers to prevent speculation and hoarding, the food and consumer affairs ministry said today."With the objective of keeping the...
Wholesale price inflation hits 3-year high on high diesel prices High fuel prices, particularly that of diesel, lifted India's wholesale price index to its highest level since the Narendra Modi government took power almost three years ago.On an overall level, wholesale price of various items jumped 6.55% in February when compared with ...
No immediate plans for universal basic income: Indian Government India's welfare budget, 2016-17The Indian government has no immediate plans or proposals to institute a scheme of 'unversal basic income' in place of the myriad social welfare scheme run by the country at present, the finance ministry said in response to a query.The clar...
Gadkari to miss ambitious highway target for 2016-17 Nitin Gadkari, who is slowly building up a reputation as a pragmatic and capable minister, is likely to face major disappointment in the ongoing financial year as his ministry is unlikely to meet the steep road construction target it set for itself.Unlike the term of the ...
DEMONETIZATION: SBI sees GDP growth fall to 6.1%, miss govt projection of 7% The country's largest bank, State Bank of India, said today that it expects the growth in India's gross domestic product to fall to 6.1% or lower in the current year from 7.9% last year due to the impact of demonetization.It said the projection by government of India's Centra...
Neem Coating of urea increased crop yields by 10% – Govt The spraying of urea, the most widely consumed fertilizer in India, with Neem oil is helping to increase the output of crops by about 10% on average, according to statistics produced by the food and agricultural ministry.The ministry found a 5.8% increase in paddy yield after...
Demonetization: Modi announces bumper prizes; 15 lakh users to get 1,000 rupees Narendra Modi announced several 'prize schemes' to promote cashless transactions.Under the schemes announced today, there will be two sets of prizes for consumers and another for small merchants.Under the first scheme, any customer who uses any electronic form of payment,...
DEMONETIZATION: Wholesale Price Inflation falls to 3.15% in November The annual rate of inflation, based on monthly WPI, stood at 3.15% for the month of November, 2016 as compared to 3.39% for the previous month and -2.04% during the corresponding month of the previous year.The fall is largely expected due to the impact of the withdrawal of h...
Petrol Pumps, Airlines Will Not Take Old Notes From Saturday | DEMONETIZATION Old notes will no longer be accepted at petrol pumps and airline ticket counters starting from Saturday, according to sources.So far, petrol pumps and airlines had been given an exemption from demonetization of 500 and 1000 rupee notes.However, in an effort to control...
Fitch revises US growth estimates on Trump election, says protectionism to rise The surge in populism and anti-establishment sentiment witnessed in the Brexit vote and Donald Trump's victory in the US presidential election seem likely to push structural policies in the direction of economic nationalism, said Fitch Ratings in its latest global economic outloo...
DEMONETIZATION: How some earned lakhs standing in queues The government has banned over-the-counter exchange of old 500- and 1000-rupee notes due to suspected gaming of the system by those with black money. According to banking industry sources, the over-the-counter exchange system was being massively misused by hawala operators and ot...
Despite Demonetization, India will beat China in GDP growth: Fitch Ratings Despite a moderation in India's GDP growth rate in the short term due to cash crunch, the Indian economy will still grow faster than that of China, global ratings agency Fitch said."We still expect India’s GDP growth to trend higher than China’s in the medium term," said the ...
Fitch says demonetization gains may not last Fitch Ratings said the positive effects are unlikely to be strong and sufficiently enduring "to support credit profiles" and will impact GDP growth in the current quarter.Though the gains will be substantial in the short-term, they may not last as people may still go back...
Hiring slows in October due to festival effect – Naukri.com Hiring activity fell 8% October this year compared to the same month a year ago, according to Naukri.com's Job Speak Index.This dip was primarily caused by the festive season which saw Dussehra, Durga Pooja and Diwali fall in October, the company said. "Hiring activity ge...
RBI chests have enough cash – ICICI Bank CEO ICICI Bank Chief Executive Officer Chanda Kocchar today said the Reserve Bank of India's currency chests have enough cash and there is no situation of scarcity for banks in securing notes.Kocchar also said that all banks including hers are bringing more and more ATMs into wo...
Chidambaram says Congress didn’t demonetize because it was costly Former finance minister P Chidambaram said the previous Congress governments had also considered attacking black money by swapping currency notes, but decided against it as it was considered too costly.Talking to mediapersons, Chidambaram said the cost of swapping the notes w...
Modi’s currency move gets Morgan Stanley thumbs up US-based Morgan Stanley has given its thumbs up to Narendra Modi's bold and unprecedented move to curb illegal funds by swapping currency notes.The government announced on late yesterday night that it will demonetise the high denomination currency -- Rs. 500 and Rs. 1000 note...
RBI’s OFFICIAL GUIDE on how to exchange currency notes of 500, 1000 The Reserve Bank of India has released the following question and answers to alleviate citizens' doubts about the new ban on 500 and 1000 rupee notes.We are reproducing the entire FAQ below for readers' convenience.Why is this scheme?The incidence of fake Indian curre...