ACC, Ambuja to challenge Competition Commission order

ACC

ACC Ltd and Ambuja Cements said they will challenge the fine imposed by the Competition Commission of India yesterday, and that a similar order passed by the CCI four years ago had been set aside by the Competition Appellate Tribunal in December last year.

“We await receipt of a certified copy of the CCI Order. The Management believes that the company has a strong case on merits to challenge the CCI order and has accordingly decided to file an appeal before the COMPAT,” the companies said in identically worded statements.

Explaining the history behind the case, ACC said the Competition Commission of India first imposed a penalty of Rs 1,147.59 crores on the company in 2012.

“The Company had subsequently filed an appeal before the Hon’ble Competition Appellate Tribunal (COMPAT) to set aside the said Order of the CCI, responding to which COMPAT had granted an interim stay while directing the Company to deposit 10 per cent of the penalty with the Commission which was complied with by the Company,” it added.

“In December 2015, the COMPAT set aside the CCI order of June 2012 while remanding the matter back to the CCI to be heard again for fresh adjudication and the 10% deposit amount was refunded to the Company.

“After hearing the matter afresh, the CCI published on its website yesterday evening an Order against the same cement manufacturers, including the Company, imposing the same penalty of Rs 1147.59 crores at a rate of 0.5 times of the profit for the years 2009-10 and 2010-11″ on the Company.”

The CCI had yesterday imposed fine of Rs 6,320.6 cr upon ten cement manufacturers for forming independent organization to limit competition by controlling the production and distribution of cement.

The list of companies included ACC Cements, Ambuja Cements, Binani Cements, Century Cements, India Cements, J K Cements, Lafarge, Ramco Cements, UltraTech Cements and Jaypee Group.

ACC Cements (Rs 1,147.59 cr), Ambuja Cements (Rs 1,163.91 cr), Ultratech Cements (Rs 1,175.49 cr) and Jaypee Group (Rs 1,323.60 cr) were the ones penalised with the highest amounts.

It was noted by CCI that the cement companies used the platform provided by Cement Manufacturers Association (CMA) and shared details relating to prices, capacity utilisation, production and dispatch and thereby restricted production and supplies in the market.

CCI also found the cement companies to be acting in concert in fixing prices of cement.


Nokia files more patent infringement suits against Apple Nokia has filed further complaints alleging that Apple products infringe a number of Nokia patents, expanding its litigation originally announced on December 21. Across actions in 11 countries, there are now 40 patents in suit, which cover technologies such as display, us...
Welspun says ‘Egyptian Cotton’ related US lawsuits not yet material Welspun said it believed that two complaints against the company for allegedly using non-Egyptian cotton may or may not be allowed to proceed as class action lawsuits, and are therefore not yet 'material'.The company was responding to a question by the stock exchanges of Indi...
CCI disposes off 80% anti-trust cases, says D.K. Sikri The fair trade regulator, Competition Commission of India (CCI), said it has disposed off more than 600 of 750 anti-trust cases handled by the Commission by now i.e. about 80 per cent of the total cases.“Of the information filed, now 80 per cent is not subject to any investig...
Wipro says ESIC withholds dues under contract IT provider Wipro Ltd said Indian government's Employees' State Insurance Corporation has withheld payments due to it after the completion of a project, and it will take legal action to recover the amount.The seven-year contract, named Project Panchdeep, was completed on June...
ACC, Ambuja among cement companies facing massive fines from Competition Commission The Competition Commission of India (CCI) has imposed fine of Rs 6,320.6 cr upon ten cement manufacturers for forming independent organization to limit competition by controlling the production and distribution of cement, said the Ministry of corporate affairs.The list of...
Birla Corporation completes acquisition of Reliance Cement Company Birla Corporation said it has completed the acquisition of Reliance Cement company (RCCPL) through purchase of 100% shares in the company.The previously Reliance Infrastructure owned company is now a wholly owned subsidiary of Birla Corporation added the company.Early in ...
Grasim’s net profit up 64% on strong viscose staple fibre sales Grasim has reported a 64% growth in profit for April-June quarter on strong performance of their Viscose Staple Fibre (VSF) subsidiary.Increase VSF demand and low inventory in China were the major reason for growth, said the company.Cement subsidiary UltraTech's profit ro...
Finance Ministry DID NOT reject Tata arbitration payment – DoCoMo Japanese telecom major DoCoMo said it was not aware of any new decision by the finance ministry on the issue of payment of arbitration amount by Tata Sons.A report by the Press Trust of India yesterday claimed that the Finance Ministry had rejected a proposal by the Reserve B...
DoCoMo reiterates Tata Sons must pay $1.17 bln DoCoMo, the Japan-based telecom group and a partner of Tata Sons in their telecom venture in India, said there are no impediments for Tata Sons to pay the penalty awarded by the London Court of International Arbitration.DoCoMo said Tata Sons should not use a recent decision b...
Anil Ambani’s Reliance Infrastructure sells Cement business to Birla Corp Birla Corporation Limited said it agreed to buy the entire cement business of Reliance Infrastructure Ltd for a valuation of Rs 4800 crores including debt.The debt portion of the valuation will not go to Reliance Infrastructure. The equity value of Reliance Cement was not di...
Nestle says will work with govt to bring Maggi back Nestle welcomed the decision by the Bombay High Court to lift the ban on Maggi noodles imposed by Food Safety and Standards Authority of India and said it expects to see the product back on shelves soon."(We) will comply with the order to undertake fresh tests," Nestle said o...
TV Today, NDTV confirm receipt of show-cause notice over Yakub Memon’s execution NDTV and TV Today said they had received show cause notices from the ministry of information and broadcasting for airing programs on the suitability of the death penalty for Yakub Memon, who was hanged to death last week."The Company firmly believes that it has not violated a...
Vedanta gets go-ahead for Goa iron ore mining Vedanta Resources, the London-listed global mining giant, said it will today restart iron-ore mining at its mine at Codli in Sanguem taluka in Goa."The Company has received the relevant consent, license and approvals in place to commence the iron-ore mining operations in the ...
No court summons over TDS – SpiceJet SpiceJet denied media reports that it had been told to appear in an income tax case by a Delhi court."..the Company has not received any summon or notice as reported in certain sections of the media," it said in a letter to the BSE.Media has reported in recent days th...
Mahindra & Mahindra launches NuPro edible oil in West Bengal The Agri Business vertical of Mahindra & Mahindra, part of the USD 16.9 billion Mahindra Group, today announced the launch of its branded edible oil - NuPro.The company, under the Nufro brand, will offer a bouquet of edible oils, starting with mustard oil. The product ...
Supreme Court stays CERC order on transfer of FTIL shares in IEX Financial Technologies said that the Supreme Court has stayed an earlier order by the Central Electricity Regulatory Commission directing Indian Energy Exchange to transfer its shares in the exchange to a trust.The CERC issued the order on June 26, 2015, directing FTIL (F...
Won’t pay CCI fine immediately – Maruti Suzuki India's largest carmaker Maruti Suzuki India Ltd has said it won't have to pay the Rs 4.7 bln fine imposed on it by the Competition Commission of India due to a Delhi High Court order.The competition commission had, in an order on Monday, found car manufactures to be indulgin...
Fund manager explains how India’s onion cartel works Sandip Sabharwal, a Mumbai-based fund manager and investment expert, has explained how unscrupulous hoarders and traders in India jack up the prices of onions.In a post on his Facebook page, Sabharwal described the exact methodology of how India's onion cartel, that pushe...
Dead insects in Fanta; Hindustan Coca-Cola to pay The National Consumer Disputes Redressal Commission of India has dismissed an appeal by Hindustan Coca-Cola Beverages, a part of The Coca-Cola Company’s Bottling Investments Group, against an order by a lower court awarding compensation to customer who found dead insects floating...
Commodity trading in India down sharply in the wake of scam, gold curbs Negative investor sentiment due to recent payment crisis in the National Spot Exchange Ltd (NSEL), sluggish participation in gold and silver futures and increased volatility following rupee have combined to pull down the turnover in India’s top commodity futures trading exchanges...