HOME > BUSINESS > How Ravishankar Prasad can resolve the 700 MHz spectrum auction pricing problem

How Ravishankar Prasad can resolve the 700 MHz spectrum auction pricing problem

broadbandIndia is getting ready for a digital revolution by auctioning 700 MHz spectrum that has the potential to take high-speed Internet to every village in the country. However, telecom operators — who have to play the role of the enablers — are not popping open the bubbly quite yet.

The reason for their misgivings is the high financial commitment that they have to make to get their hands on 700 MHz spectrum.

A LITTLE BACKGROUND

Cellular spectrum can be divided into two types — high priced, high propagation and low priced, low propagation.

As the name implies, the first type covers a lot of distance, but costs more; while the second type comes cheap, but covers only a smaller area.

Why is this important? If more area can be covered by a single tower, that saves a lot of money for operators who can then sell their service at a lower cost.

For example, if you were to use the current, popular band of 2300 MHz to set up a 4G network, you will need around 6 lakh towers to achieve pan-India coverage. And it’s not just the 6 lakh towers — you also need to connect these towers using a fiber network too.

If, on the other hand, you are using 700 MHz spectrum, you can achieve the same coverage using 1 lakh or fewer towers. In fact, CDMA operators have achieved near ubiquitous coverage on the adjoining 800 MHz spectrum with less than 50,000 towers nationally.

This reduction in the number of towers can save operators a lot of money. An average cell site costs around Rs 30,000 per month, or Rs 3.6 lakhs per year. Over the 20-year lifespan of the auctioned airwaves, the total cost per tower works out to Rs 72 lakhs.

So, if an operator chooses 700 MHz spectrum instead of 2300 MHz, he can save at least Rs 72 lakh multiplied by 5 lakh, which works out to Rs 36,00,00,00,00,000 or Rs 3.6 lakh crore.

In addition, this also saves the operator from having to build lakhs of km of fiber backbone to connect these high-speed towers, which would be another substantial amount. In total, therefore, the switch to 700 MHz would save them Rs 5 lakh cr or more during the validity period of the airwaves.

Now, let’s compare this savings with the price of the spectrum. The TRAI has suggested a base price of Rs 1.15 lakh cr for a decent 10 MHz block, compared to a price of around Rs 8,200 cr for the low-propagation 2300 MHz band.

In other words, to make the switch from 2300 MHz to 700 MHz and save Rs 5 lakh cr in tower and fiber costs, operators have to pay an extra Rs 1.07 lakh cr over the next 13 years in terms of spectrum charges.

The choice, you’d think, is not that difficult to make. After all, if you can save Rs 5 lakh cr over the next 20 years by paying Rs 1 lakh cr in the next 13 years, why wouldn’t you?

TOO LONG A PERIOD?

The problem is that no one really knows what is going to happen to wireless telecom in the next 20 years. In fact, it’s difficult to predict what will happen in the next 8 years.

This makes telecom companies wary of committing such a huge amount of money.

Even Mukesh Ambani’s Reliance Industries, which has invested Rs 1 lakh cr over the past 3 years in its telecom venture Reliance Jio, doesn’t have the stomach to shell out another Rs 1 lakh cr.

Reliance Jio, like Bharti Airtel and Idea Cellular, asked the government to postpone the sale of the 700 MHz spectrum.

The problem is not the price itself as much as the duration of the commitment.

For example, the savings of Rs 5 lakh cr over 20 years translates to a saving of Rs 25,000 cr per year, while the spectrum price of Rs 1.15 lakh cr for 20 years translates to just Rs 5,750 cr per year.

Looked at in this way, it makes total sense for the company to pay Rs 5,750 cr and save Rs 25,000 cr next year.

But the catch is that the government is seeking a commitment for 20 years when no one is able to predict with any certainty what the shape of the business will be in the longer term.

For all you know, new light-based or satellite-based technology could reduce the value of this spectrum to nothing after 10 years. Just like technology can reduce the spectrum value in the future, it could also increase it manifold, and Rs 1 lakh cr could look like peanuts after five years. No one really knows.

As a result, the operators are wary of shelling out the amounts and want the government to give the spectrum cheaper to them by reducing the reserve price. Of course, lower prices would also help increase any windfall gains they stand to make 10  years from now.

More justifiably, the operators justifiably point out that they are not in the business of speculation, but communication. By insisting on selling spectrum for 20 years, the government is forcing telecom companies a speculative play on the value of the spectrum in the future.

If both parties are adamant in their stands, there is a possibility that the operators could boycott the 700 MHz auction.

This would be a set back for India as a country, as there is nothing — except Reliance Jio’s 800 MHz service — that can replace this band in taking broadband to the villages.

THE SOLUTION

The ideal solution is reduce the risk for the operators, while protecting the interests of the public of the country by ensuring a fair valuation. This can be achieved by cutting the tenure of the spectrum award.

In other words, in addition to the price, let operators also bid for tenure. So, instead of putting in a bid for Rs 50,000 cr for 20 years, allow them to bid for Rs 5,000 cr for five years, which they are most likely to.

In fact, given the potential valuation upside to wireless spectrum in the next 8-12 years, it would also be unfair to the taxpayers to ‘sell’ this spectrum for 20 years and let the operators keep any upside to the valuation in the future.

If variable tenure sounds complicated, the government can also just cut the validity period of the airwaves in half — to 10 years.

This will not prevent operators from buying the airwaves or building new networks using this spectrum. Reliance Jio, Reliance Communications and Tata Teleservices are deploying 4G networks on spectrum that is valid only till 2022 — another six years.

Follow ULTRA.news
Reliance Communications says MTS merger to be closed in 2 weeks, gets DoT nod Reliance Communication Ltd said it received the approval of Department of Telecommunication (DoT) for its merger with Sistema Shyam Teleservices Limited or SSTL, which runs MTS branded services in India.With this, the Anil Ambani Group company has received all the major regu...
BSNL gives ‘free broadband for 1 month’ via FB, Twitter State-owned Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd said it would offer one month of its wired services -- DSL, landline or fiber -- free if the booking is made via Twitter or Facebook.The user will have to pay security deposits and installation charges, if any. However, he or she will get...
Why Reliance JIO’s new tariff plan is BAD for Bharti Airtel, Idea & Vodafone Airtel's stock performance (2002-2017)The stock of Bharti Airtel is at a two-year high, not far from its life-highs of late 2007, but going by the latest tariffs unveiled by Reliance Jio, investors will do well to hold off on the bubbly for a while longer.Airtel closed a...
The Economics of Bharti Airtel’s 7777 offer on the iPhone 8 Bharti Airtel announced that it will sell high-end smartphones online with instant financing.The phones, including the iPhone 8, will be available at low downpayment and bundled monthly packages, which will make them more or less free of charge.The model was first tried ...
Bharti Airtel merges Ghana arm with Tigo of Millicom Bharti Airtel said it is merging its operations in the African nation of Ghana with the local unit of Millicom International Cellular."Under the joint agreement, Airtel and Millicom will have equal ownership (50:50) and governance rights in the combined entity, which will ha...
Reliance Jio’s New 4G Plans: No More Tariff Increases? Jio's new 4G tariff from Oct 19Reliance Jio has unveiled a set of new plans that will come into effect from tomorrow, effecting a price increase of about 15% to existing tariff.The phrasing of the new plans also suggests that these are 'regular' plans, and not promotiona...
Reliance Jio to withdraw Rs 399 plan next week Most customers of Reliance Jio, the country's largest telecom operator by volumes, will not be able to get the 84GB-for-399 plan starting next month, the company's deputy chief financial officer V Srikant said on Friday.Asked how the company's average revenue per user (billi...
Reliance Jio breaks even on opg level, 9.62 GB avg consumption per month Reliance Jio has reported revenue of Rs 7,213 cr and an operating profit of Rs 261 cr for the second quarter of the financial year.Per capita data consumption was 9.62 GB per user per month.Average voice consumption was 626 minutes per month during the period, it added. ...
Tata Tele acquisition good for Bharti Airtel – Fitch Bharti Airtel Limited's (BBB-/Stable) announcement that it plans to acquire the consumer mobile operations of Tata Teleservices and Tata Teleservices (Maharashtra) Ltd (Tata Telecom business) is positive for the deal participants as well as the industry, Fitch Ratings said.B...
Reliance Jio quarterly numbers to be announced today; new tariff plans eyed Reliance Industries, the parent of telecom operator Jio, will announce its quarterly performance numbers at around 5 pm today.Besides its core oil and gas business, the company will give an update on the operations of its telecom unit.Some in the market even expect it t...
Tata Teleservices to merge mobile business with Bharti Airtel Bharti Airtel Limited, India’s largest telecommunications services provider and Tata, India’s leading conglomerate, today announced that they have entered into an understanding to merge Consumer Mobile Businesses (CMB) of TTSL and TTML into Bharti Airtel.The move is likely ...
Reliance Jio to launch new plans on Thursday, offers 100% cashback Reliance Jio, India's most popular wireless data provider, said it will introduce new plans from Oct 19, and that it was offering "100%" cashback on its popular recharge of Rs 399 that gives three months of services.In a promotion put up on its website, the company said the ...
Airtel counters JioPhone with smartphone at Rs 1,399 net price Bharti Airtel has announced a scheme to offer a 4-inch smartphone at an effective price of Rs 1,399 -- after cash backs -- to take on the challenge posed by Reliance Jio's Jiophone.The customer needs to make a down payment of Rs 2899 for the 4G smartphone. He will get a cash...
Tata Tele Maharasthra loses 3.5% mobile subscribers in Sept Tata Teleservices Maharashtra Ltd has lost 3.5% of its mobile subscribers in September.The company, which offers mobile and wired telecom services in Maharashtra, Mumbai and Goa saw its mobile users fall to 69.8 lakh (6.98 mln) on September 30 from 72.4 lakh at the end of Au...
Idea, Airtel offer 84 GB 4g data for Rs 400 to target users Airtel PlansIdea Cellular and Bharti Airtel are offering 1 GB of 3G or 4G data per day for 84 days at a price of around Rs 400 in select circles, including voice benefits, matching Jio's lowest tariff.The offer is available only for targeted users.For example, for so...
To arrest subscriber decline, Idea offers 84 GB, on-net calls for 230 rupees Idea Cellular, the third largest telecom operator in India by revenue, has started offering new customers 84 GB and free on-net calls for 84 days for just Rs 230 in the Kerala circle.Similar schemes are likely to have been launched in other circles as well.It also offers ...
Zain to use Wifi spectrum to speed up 4G LTE Nokia will help Saudi telecom operator Zain to use unlicensed spectrum in the 5 GHz band -- often used for Wifi -- to increase download speeds of 4G LTE."Following the trial, the Nokia technology will be deployed in hotspots, for example, in malls and cafes in Jeddah and aro...
Idea Cellular offers 28 GB 3G/4G data for Rs 250 Idea Cellular, which has been under pressure in recent months due to aggressive offerings from rivals Bharti Airtel and Reliance Jio, has unveiled a new promotional offer that gives 1 GB per day for 28 days at a price of around Rs 250.Unlike other plans, this one does not off...
RCom likely to shut more 2G, 3G networks, sell the spectrum Reliance Communications, which announced it was abandoning plans to merge with Aircel Cellular, indicated that it would focus on two segments - 4G and wired. Within wired, it would focus on enterprise services.The disclosure indicates that the company, -- which recently shut ...
JIO IMPACT: India mobile data usage up 500%, price down 97% in 1 year The average data consumed by wireless users in India has increased five fold in the last year one year, even as prices crashed by 97% due to the launch of Reliance Jio.For India as a whole, the total consumption of wireless data touched 4.3 bln GB in the three months from Ap...