HOME > BUSINESS > Ookla explains in detail why Jio’s fears on speedtest results are misplaced

Ookla explains in detail why Jio’s fears on speedtest results are misplaced

Airtel’s new ad

Some may call it a storm in a tea cup, but the Ookla-Jio-Airtel controversy has turned out to be a one with an unexpectedly long life.

After coming up with a half-hearted defence two days ago, Ookla — the provider of the world’s most popular mobile and broadband speed testing service — today gave a more detailed explanation of why its data crowning Bharti Airtel as India’s fastest network is reliable.

Airtel’s rival Reliance Jio had taken issue with Ookla’s test methodology, pointing out that the app was reporting the carrier used by the SIM in the first slot of a dual SIM handset even if the test was done on the second SIM.

Ookla said it doesn’t matter, as it does not rely on the carrier value reported by the app.

“Due to limitations of the Android platform, the “Active Carrier” does not always indicate the actual data provider in devices with multiple SIMs. In these situations, Ookla applies additional data sources and mechanisms during postprocessing to help determine the actual data carrier being tested.

“For example, Ookla matches the connection IP address recorded during the test to known carrier IP blocks. This enables Ookla to determine the actual data carrier with a high degree of confidence,” it said.

Airtel has created an ad campaign on the subject as part of its attempts to bounce back into prominence after it was sidelined by free data services offered by Jio.

According to some estimates, Jio is carrying 94% of India’s wireless data traffic, while Airtel’s share has been reduced to 2%.

However, due to the tremendous amount of data carried by Jio, the average speed experienced by a subscriber on the network is reported to have fallen to ‘just’ 8.34 Mbps in January.

The reverse seems to be happening with Airtel. As capacity utilization declines, speeds on Airtel have increased, doubling to 8.42 in January from 4.68 Mbps in the preceding month, according to user-reported data from the website of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India.

Similar numbers were announced by Ookla earlier this month, showing that on average, Airtel users experienced faster connections.

‘FASTEST NETWORK’ 

Airtel, which in 2015 was forced by the Advertising Standards Council of India to withdraw a similar ‘fastest network’ ad, seized on the opportunity to come up with a new campaign calling itself the ‘fastest network in India’.

However, Jio said its data was being misinterpreted as belonging to Airtel due to faulty reporting by handsets.

This was followed by a brief reaction two days ago by Ookla, saying it ‘stood by’ its previous assertion without giving further explanation.

WHO IS RIGHT?

According to telecom and IT experts we spoke with, the likelihood of Ookla mistakenly ascribing Jio’s test results to Airtel based on the carrier reported by Android is extremely remote.

“Ookla has its own system of determining the carrier independent of the handset,” pointed out an official from a third telecom company that has nothing to do with the controversy, but hosts several Ookla test servers.

“Remember that their speed test also works on PCs, where there is no SIM card to identify the network with,” he added. “The primary method they use to figure out which carrier is being used by the subscriber is the IP address.”

DOES IT MATTER?

Telecom officials, and even some consumers, are amused by the heat generated by the controversy.

General opinion is that consumers do not choose their telecom provider based on average speeds reported by apps, but by real speeds that they experience in their daily lives.

“I think this whole controversy is funny,” said the above official, who we cannot name as he is not authorized to give statements to the media.

“If a consumer is stuck with a poor connectivity in his area, or if he has to spend three times as much for an 8 Mbps connection compared to a 7 Mbps connection, these kind of claims have no meaning,” he said.

Broadly, however, industry sees the controversy as a marketing victory for Airtel as the reams of headlines have helped draw attention to its ‘fastest network’ claim better than any ad campaign.

Follow ULTRA.news
BSNL STVs now valid on roaming as well BSNL, the state-owned telecommunications company, said it has decided to extent the benefits of all special recharges to its subscribers even when they're roaming.So far, these special tariffs were available only in the home location.For example, STV 349 which offers unli...
Reliance Jio starts turning off free services, urges users to recharge Reliance Jio, the telecom firm that has caught the country by storm, has started turning off the connections of those subscribers who have not recharged their mobile phones since the beginning of April.In April, it had introduced the Summer Surprise offer, and gave around fou...
TRAI to hear the public on net neutrality in open house this month The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India has started registrations for an open house discussion on its upcoming recommendations on net neutrality.The open house discussion will be held on Wednesday, August 30 at 9:30 AM in New Delhi. The venue has not been finalized yet, and...
Idea Cellular likely to expand 4G offers this year Idea Cellular, India's third biggest telecom player by revenue, is likely to see its 4G data capacity rise to three times the current level over the next nine months, which is likely to push the price of data down further.This could impact Reliance Jio's ability to stop its d...
Vodafone slashes 4G offer prices after Airtel, Idea reveal explosion of data Vodafone India renewed efforts to promote its cut-price voice and data offerings in recent days as the latest quarterly numbers from rivals Idea Cellular and Bharti Airtel suggested they had given out bigger discounts in the April-June period than anyone had expected.Earlier ...
Bharti Airtel will launch VoLTE next year Bharti Airtel is still testing its 4G voice or Voice over LTE service and a pan-India launch will take place only by January-March of 2018.Gopal Vittal"VoLTE is a very complex technology," CEO Gopal Vittal said. "There is a lot of optimization. It has to be tested device...
No plans to launch JioPhone rival – Bharti Airtel Bharti Airtel, India's largest telecom provider by revenue, said it has no intention of launching a rival phone similar to the super-cheap semi-smartphone launched by rival Reliance Jio.Asked if the company needed to come out with a similar, affordable handset to compete with...
Telecom license fees fall 23% as Reliance Jio hits call, data prices The license fees paid by telecom operators in India to the central government fell by 23% to 2,663 crore in the three months ended March compared to the previous three months, the government said.Compared to nine months earlier, the fall was 33%.Telecom access providers, ...
HALVED: Bharti Airtel’s data price crashes to Rs 60/GB due to Reliance Jio Bharti Airtel was forced to slash its data price by half to about Rs 60 per GB in the April to June period of 2017, the latest numbers revealed.In contrast, Bharti Airtel was charging around Rs 125 per GB in the three months from January to March of this year. A year ago, it ...
Bharti Airtel profit down 75%, says market remains “turbulent” Bharti Airtel Limited reported a drop of 14% in its revenue for the first quarter, at Rs 21,958 crore. Adjusted for sale of its units, the drop was 11%, it said.Net profit fell 75% to 367 crore rupees for the first quarter. Operating profit was down 18%.India revenues for...
Bharti Airtel Q1 revenue up 10%, profit down 12% Tower provider Bharti Infratel reported a 10% growth in its revenue and profit for the first quarter.The Consolidated revenues for the quarter, at Rs. 3,524 Crore, was up by 10% over the corresponding period last year.Consolidated profit from operations improved to Rs 1,...
Is the Reliance Jio’s JioPhone really free? The latest entrant to India's telecom market, Reliance Jio, has announced an unprecedented offer -- a 4G enabled phone with support for apps and videocalling for free.According to Mukesh Ambani, customers do not have to pay anything for the phone as the cost of the phone will...
JIOPHONE: Reliance Jio to give unlimited data at Rs 153 / month Reliance Jio chairman Mukesh Ambani announced the JioPhone, which aims to bring smartphone features to the candybar form factor.The phone will be given to anyone if they deposit Rs 1500 with the company. The user will get the Rs 1500 back when the device is returned after 36 ...
Reliance Jio offers phone for ‘free’, unlimited voice, data at Rs 153 Reliance Jio chairman Mukesh Ambani announced the JioPhone, which aims to bring smartphone features to the candybar form factor.The phone will be given to anyone if they deposit Rs 1500 with the company. The user will get the Rs 1500 back when the device is returned after 36 ...
WATCH HERE: Mukesh Ambani speech on Reliance Jio at AGM today Mukesh Ambani, chairman of Reliance Jio will make a 'significant announcement' about the 4G wireless service provider's offerings at 11 AM on Friday while delivering his annual speech at its parent's annual general meeting.A live webcast of Mukesh Ambani's speech at the AGM, a...
BSNL halves 2Mbps unlimited plan to Rs 599 from 1,199 Faced with a slowdown due to the emergence of the pan-India competitor Reliance Jio, state-owned Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd has halved the price of its unlimited 2 Mbps DSL broadband plan to 599 per month.BSNL NEW UNLIMITED BROADBAND PLANThe player was earlier offering unl...
Spectranet overtakes Airtel Broadband on Netflix speed ranking for India Netflix, the world's biggest distributor of movies, ranked Mumbai-based 7 Star cable network and Spectranet, which offers fiber broadband in several cities, as the fastest networks for prime time usage.The average speed available to Netflix was 2.77 Mbps on 7 Star cable and 2...
With tariff change, Idea Cellular 4G data now cheaper than Reliance Jio Idea 4G tariff planWith Reliance Jio raising the price of its 1GB-per-day pack from Rs 309 to Rs 399, Idea Cellular has managed to beat the new operator in this segment, though not by much.Idea Cellular offers 1GB/day for 84 days at Rs 397, making it cheaper by 2 rupees....
Reliance Jio users should recharge with new plans by Friday for continued service Most Reliance Jio 4G users have to recharge their phones by Friday, July 14 to continue uninterrupted service.This because the current offer -- Summer Surprise or Dhan Dhana Dhan -- came into effect on April 16, and will complete 90 days by Friday.The Summer Surprise pla...
RELIANCE JIO unveils NEW PLANS valid from today Reliance Jio's new tariff plansIndia's biggest wireless data provider Reliance Jio unveiled a new set of plans as it continues to migrate its customers towards paid plans.The key difference between the new plans and the previous Dhan Dhana Dhan offer is that the new plan...
LAST CHANCE: Reliance Jio’s Dhan Dhana Dhan offer ends today Today marks the last day of telecom operator Reliance Jio's Dhan Dhana Dhan promotional offer that triples the validity of 4G recharges on its platform.The offer was unveiled as a promotional scheme on April 11, and according to the law, promotional schemes can be valid only ...
RCom says telcos facing cash flow issues due to ‘go slow’ approach by banks Telecom operator Reliance Communications said companies in the sector are facing cash flow issues due to what it called a 'go slow' approach taken by banks in disbursing loans.In an update on its 'standstill agreement' with its lenders, which provides it a window of seven mon...
Reliance Jio to offer 5 GB/day for Rs 999 per month Users of the JioFi, the personal hotspot device from Reliance Jio, will be able to get a new plan that takes the free data offered per day to 5 GB.At present, the highest amount of free data that any user on the 4G service can get is 2 GB, for a payment of around Rs 500 for 2...
Reliance Jio tops in user satisfaction, but call drop concerns remain Percentage of customers giving 4 or 5 starsReliance Jio users are a happier lot than customers of other services, but call drops and network availability remain key concerns, according to a survey conducted by a market research firm Velocity MR.The firm conducted a study...
Vodafone India offers unlimited downloading for 5 hours at Rs 29 Taking a leaf from new entrant Reliance Jio's playbook, Vodafone India has announced a 'truly unlimited' five-hour data pack for Rs 29.The pack, called Vodafone SuperNight, will work between 1 AM and 6 AM and is open for prepaid customers only. It will work on both 3G and 4G...