HOME > BUSINESS > Ookla explains in detail why Jio’s fears on speedtest results are misplaced

Ookla explains in detail why Jio’s fears on speedtest results are misplaced

Airtel’s new ad

Some may call it a storm in a tea cup, but the Ookla-Jio-Airtel controversy has turned out to be a one with an unexpectedly long life.

After coming up with a half-hearted defence two days ago, Ookla — the provider of the world’s most popular mobile and broadband speed testing service — today gave a more detailed explanation of why its data crowning Bharti Airtel as India’s fastest network is reliable.

Airtel’s rival Reliance Jio had taken issue with Ookla’s test methodology, pointing out that the app was reporting the carrier used by the SIM in the first slot of a dual SIM handset even if the test was done on the second SIM.

Ookla said it doesn’t matter, as it does not rely on the carrier value reported by the app.

“Due to limitations of the Android platform, the “Active Carrier” does not always indicate the actual data provider in devices with multiple SIMs. In these situations, Ookla applies additional data sources and mechanisms during postprocessing to help determine the actual data carrier being tested.

“For example, Ookla matches the connection IP address recorded during the test to known carrier IP blocks. This enables Ookla to determine the actual data carrier with a high degree of confidence,” it said.

Airtel has created an ad campaign on the subject as part of its attempts to bounce back into prominence after it was sidelined by free data services offered by Jio.

According to some estimates, Jio is carrying 94% of India’s wireless data traffic, while Airtel’s share has been reduced to 2%.

However, due to the tremendous amount of data carried by Jio, the average speed experienced by a subscriber on the network is reported to have fallen to ‘just’ 8.34 Mbps in January.

The reverse seems to be happening with Airtel. As capacity utilization declines, speeds on Airtel have increased, doubling to 8.42 in January from 4.68 Mbps in the preceding month, according to user-reported data from the website of the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India.

Similar numbers were announced by Ookla earlier this month, showing that on average, Airtel users experienced faster connections.

‘FASTEST NETWORK’ 

Airtel, which in 2015 was forced by the Advertising Standards Council of India to withdraw a similar ‘fastest network’ ad, seized on the opportunity to come up with a new campaign calling itself the ‘fastest network in India’.

However, Jio said its data was being misinterpreted as belonging to Airtel due to faulty reporting by handsets.

This was followed by a brief reaction two days ago by Ookla, saying it ‘stood by’ its previous assertion without giving further explanation.

WHO IS RIGHT?

According to telecom and IT experts we spoke with, the likelihood of Ookla mistakenly ascribing Jio’s test results to Airtel based on the carrier reported by Android is extremely remote.

“Ookla has its own system of determining the carrier independent of the handset,” pointed out an official from a third telecom company that has nothing to do with the controversy, but hosts several Ookla test servers.

“Remember that their speed test also works on PCs, where there is no SIM card to identify the network with,” he added. “The primary method they use to figure out which carrier is being used by the subscriber is the IP address.”

DOES IT MATTER?

Telecom officials, and even some consumers, are amused by the heat generated by the controversy.

General opinion is that consumers do not choose their telecom provider based on average speeds reported by apps, but by real speeds that they experience in their daily lives.

“I think this whole controversy is funny,” said the above official, who we cannot name as he is not authorized to give statements to the media.

“If a consumer is stuck with a poor connectivity in his area, or if he has to spend three times as much for an 8 Mbps connection compared to a 7 Mbps connection, these kind of claims have no meaning,” he said.

Broadly, however, industry sees the controversy as a marketing victory for Airtel as the reams of headlines have helped draw attention to its ‘fastest network’ claim better than any ad campaign.

Follow ULTRA.news
After Reliance Jio, Idea offers 100% cashback on Rs 357 plan Idea Cellular, reportedly India's third largest 4G operator by volume, has started offering a 100% cash-back scheme even as the Cellular Operators Association has complained against such schemes.Similar cash back schemes have been announced by Reliance Jio in an effort to ma...
As Jio reality sinks, Idea abandons ‘limited aggression’ strategy Idea Cellular has abandoned its earlier strategy of 'limited aggression' in dealing with the threat from Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel, and will be more visible in its counter strikes from now, said CEO Himanshu Kapania."From end October, Idea has shifted its earlier stand ...
Idea sees half of India remain 2G-only in 2022, to refarm 900 MHz for 4G About 600-650 mln telecom customers in India will remain 'pure 2G' users even in the year 2022, while 4G users would swell from 175 mln to 750 mln, said Himanshu Kapania, CEO of India's fourth largest telecom operator Idea Cellular.At present, India has around 1.05 bln activ...
Bharti Airtel raises Rs 3,325 cr by selling shares in Infratel Bharti Airtel said it raised Rs 3,325 crore (USD 510 Million) by selling shares in its tower subsidiary.It sold 83 mln shares at Rs 400.60 each. The price was at a discount of 3.6% to the previous day’s closing level.Shares of Infratel opened down by about 4% today due ...
Tata Teleservices loses 7.3% subscribers in October in Maharashtra Tata Teleservices, the mobile telecom arm of the Tata Group that was sold to Bharti Airtel last month, lost about 7.3% of its nearly 7 mln mobile subscribers in Maharashtra and Goa, according to a regulatory filing by the company.Tata Telservices Maharashtra Ltd, as the compa...
Bharti Airtel unveils new postpaid plan 499 with 20 GB data Bharti Airtel said it had introduced new 4G plans for its postpaid, or contract, customers, bringing some of the benefits that were hitherto available only to the prepaid segment.The new plan has been priced at Rs 499 plan for the postpaid segment.However, compared to pr...
Airtel Broadband users get to ‘carry over’ unused data to next cycle Bharti Airtel said its home broadband users will get to carry over all unused data benefit to the next billing cycle up to a limit of 1,000 GB."This is a first of its kind innovation in the fixed home broadband segment in India. The 'Data Rollower facility will ensure that Ai...
4G prices to stay low for a year – Airtel unveils cheap 1-yr plan If there are people who expect data prices to rise substantially in the next one year, they are probably not working at Bharti Airtel.India's biggest telecom firm by revenue has unveiled long-term recharges that allow users to lock in the current cheap prices for up to a yea...
Reliance Industries to raise Rs 5,000 cr next week via listed debentures Reliance Industries said it would raise Rs 5,000 cr from the debt market by issuing debentures on Wednesday, November 8.Jio has taken the market by stormThe debentures issued will not be convertible to equity shares and will be sold privately (private placement) without ...
Hathway Broadband starts FTTH, data use up 26% in 3 months Hathway Digital said it has started rolling out fiber-to-the-home services in congested areas, and also reported a strong increase in data use after slashing prices and increase quotas.For the three months ended September, an average consumer on Hathway Broadband increased h...
Post Bharti Airtel deal, Tata DoCoMo reaches out to worried subscribers Photo by Adithya VikramTata DoCoMo has started reaching out to customers to prevent them from leaving the network in droves, ahead of a takeover of the mobile operations by Bharti Airtel.Subscribers of Tata DoCoMo, a brand operated by Tata Teleservices, had started porti...
RCom could sell assets to Reliance Jio, go virtual – Fitch Reliance Communications could ink more spectrum selling and sharing agreements with Mukesh Ambani-controlled Reliance Jio, Fitch Ratings said, adding that the Anil Ambani company would end up as a mobile virtual operator after its ongoing restructuring.RCom promoter Anil Amb...
Bharti Airtel ARPU falls below Jio’s; but data usage zooms Bharti Airtel, India's largest telecom company by revenue, reported further erosion in its revenue and profit in September quarter compared to the previous June quarter.The company reported revenue of 21,777 cr, down 12.3% compared to a year ago and down 0.8% compared to the...
Bharti Airtel Q2 profit margin up, but ARPU falls Bharti Airtel, India's largest telecom company by revenue, reported further erosion in its revenue and profit in September quarter compared to the previous June quarter.The company reported revenue of 21,777 cr, down 12.3% compared to a year ago and down 0.8% compared to t...
BSNL to increase broadband speed to 10 Mbps from tomorrow Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd has increased the speed of all its broadband to 10 Mbps from 2-4 Mbps from tomorrow for all plans starting from Rs 675 per month.This price and data allocation of the plans will remain unchanged, it said.For plans below Rs 675 per month, the down...
Bharti Infratel to try to buy Vodafone & Idea stake in Indus Towers Bharti Infratel, the tower arm of Bharti Airtel, said it has decided to explore the possibility of buying out the stakes of Idea Cellular and Vodafone in rival tower company Indus.Bharti and Vodafone currently own about 42% each in Indus, while Idea holds about 11%. As a res...
Bharti Airtel offers one more 4G phone for Rs 1,349 effective price After Karbonn, Bharti Airtel has now tied up with Celkon to offer a full touchscreen 4G smartphone at an effective price of Rs 1,349 and an upfront cost of Rs 2,849.The partnership is part of Airtel’s ‘Mera Pehla Smartphone’ initiative. It had announced a similar offer in as...
Reliance Jio impact could be ‘painful’ for banks, but good for industry – Ind-Ra Credit rating agency India Ratings has warned that the ongoing consolidation in the telecom industry caused by the entry of Reliance Jio will be painful for lenders and banks, but was good for the industry as whole.It said it had become difficult for smaller players to survi...
Post GSM shutdown, RCom may build own 4G network separate from Jio’s Reliance Communications today said that it was 'optimizing' its 2G and 3G networks in the light of its decision to focus on 4G, but also dropped a hint it may use the towers and infrastructure to later launch its own, fully-owned 4G network.At present, it depends on Relianc...
Cognizant to beef up digital practice with acquisition of Zone Continuing the trend of IT outsourcing companies topping up their digital practice with targeted acquisitions, Cognizant said it agreed to acquire Zone, a digital agency specializing in customer experience, digital strategy, technology and content creation.The transaction i...