HOME > BUSINESS > COMMUNICATION > Reliance Jio could replace Summer Surprise with new offer after TRAI order

Reliance Jio could replace Summer Surprise with new offer after TRAI order

Reliance Jio’s withdrawal of its Summer Surprise Offer is unlikely to make any difference to most of its customers, and the company may even come up with a new version of the plan to comply with the ban.

“The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has advised Jio to withdraw the 3 months complimentary benefits of Summer Surprise…

We are in the process of fully complying with the regulator’s advice, and will be withdrawing the 3 months complimentary benefits of Jio Summer Surprise as soon as operationally feasible, over the next few days,” it said in a statement late night.

The phrasing of the statement implies that TRAI asked it to withdraw the ‘three months complementary benefits’ rather than the scheme itself.

In other words, the ‘three month free service’ could be replaced with some equally attractive — something that gives an equivalent benefit.

UPDATE: The company has revealed that new plans are being worked on and will soon be revealed.

To make it clear, under the present scheme, consumers get three months of daily-data plans free for subscribing for one month. In other words, it is selling four for the price of one and the price of one is reduced to 25%.

Now, what the operator is saying is that it will withdraw the ‘free three month offer’ under the SS plan. This likely means that the Summer Surprise plan may not be withdrawn, but could come with a different set of benefits after 2-3 days.

It could, for example, slash the price of its 303 plan to Rs 76 per month under a revamped offer. This would give the same benefit to the user as the current offer, even as it escapes the charge that it is providing its service free of charge.

The second aspect of the ‘withdrawal’ is that the operator is likely to take another “few days” days to complete it and people will continue to sign on during this period.

NO IMMEDIATE IMPACT

“Next few days” usually means over the next 2-4 days, which means that the offer will not be available for new sign-ups from the 10th or 11th of this month.

That is unlikely to come as a big shock to customers as the scheme was originally set to close on Apr 15.

Moreover, about half of Jio’s Prime subscribers are already likely to have availed of the offer and the other half are likely to do so over the next 2-4 days.

If Jio manages to get 80-90 mln of its subscribers under Summer Surprise, it would have met its goal with the scheme.

PREDATORY PRICING THREAT

The primary reason for coming out with three month schemes instead of having cheap tariffs on a permanent basis could be the threat of litigation by rivals alleging predatory pricing.

So, if the Ambani firm replaces the ‘three months free’ offer by reducing its monthly charge to Rs 75 for 1 GB per day, existing operators are likely to raise the predatory pricing issue before the Competition Commission of India.

But can they really make the charge stick?

The relevant Indian rule on predatory pricing is the Competition Act of 2002.

According to the Competition Commission website, a situation must meet three conditions to qualify as ‘predatory pricing’:

First, the goods or services must be sold below the cost of manufacturing or providing the service.

Secondly, offering such goods or services should be seen as threatening the existence of rival competitors and in the long run, reducing overall competition in the market.

And finally, the third condition is that the company engaging in predatory pricing must have a ‘dominant position’ in the market.

FIRST CONDITION

If Reliance Jio offers its 303 plan at Rs 75 per month, that would imply a price of around Rs 2 per GB, which the rivals are likely to argue is ‘below cost’.

In other words, the company cannot sustain its business if it prices data at Rs 2 per GB and is therefore providing it below cost, they could say.

Jio could counter that BSNL is offering a truly unlimited 3G connection at Rs 1,099 per month — under which 1 GB would cost less than Rs 2.

RIVALS AND DOMINANCE

But it is the remaining two conditions that they could have some trouble applying to this case.

The second condition is that Jio’s offer of 1 GB per day for four months for Rs 303 must threaten the existence of rivals like Bharti Airtel, Idea Cellular and Vodafone India.

This is something that they will find hard to prove, as these companies are still making profit and even if they are pushed into the red for a period of four months, they are unlikely to go out of business.

Finally, the third condition is that Jio must be in a ‘dominant position’ in the telecom market in India.

This is open to interpretation and the arguments on this count could go on for months, if not years. According to the Competition Act, various factors must be evaluated to determine if a company is dominant in a market.

These factors include overall revenue market share (which is practically zero for Jio), overall volume market share (which is very high), the size and economic resources of the company (which is also high), strength of competitors and other market structures.

In other words, just the determination of the question — does Reliance enjoy dominant position in telecom market in India — will likely require several months.

And even if it is held that it enjoys a dominant position, the Competition Commission still has to decide issues such as whether Jio’s four-month offer is likely to lead to its competitors shutting down or not and so forth.

LEGAL PROVISIONS IN INDIA

Predatory Pricing definition from CCI website

The following is the definition of predatory pricing in the Competition Act.

“Predatory price” under the Act means “the sale of goods or provision of services, at a price which is below the cost, as may be determined by regulations, of production of goods or provision of services, with a view to reduce competition or eliminate the competitors”

The Act also offers the following explanation:

Predation is exclusionary behaviour and can be indulged in only by enterprises(s) having dominant position in the concerned relevant market. The major elements involved in the determination of predatory behaviour are: 1) Establishment of dominant position of the enterprise in the relevant market. 2) Pricing below cost for the relevant product in the relevant market by the dominant enterprise.  3) Intention to reduce competition or eliminate competitors.

 

Follow ULTRA.news
RCom lenders get first round of bids for spectrum, fiber and assets – report The lenders of Reliance Communications have got initial bids for the company's assets from the three big telecom companies in India, CNBC TV18 reported, quoting banking sources.The Anil Ambani Group company is under the control of its lenders after it ran aground due to high...
Airtel’s new 4G pack is 30% cheaper than Reliance Jio Bharti Airtel has unveiled two new publicly available 4G plans with 2 GB and 3 GB of data allocation per day, along with free voice and SMS benefits.These plans are unique as currently no other operator offers 2GB or 3G per day at these price levels.Airtel has priced its ...
Bharti Airtel offers cashback on Intex 2GB RAM models, others Continuing with its tie-ups with hardware brands, Bharti Airtel announced three more 'cash back' models from Intex, including one with 2GB of RAM.The cheapest will be the Intex Aqua LIONS N1, priced at Rs 3,149 and eligible for for a cash back of Rs 1,500 over a period of th...
Bharti Airtel invests in e-publishing platform Juggernaut Bharti Airtel said it has acquired a strategic stake in Juggernaut Books, a popular digital epublishing platform.Telecom companies in India are busy building or buying content companies in an effort to offer their own content on their networks."The investment is in line ...
Vodafone offers 1GB/day for 84 days at Rs 509 Vodafone has unveiled five pan-India plans, the highlight of which is the new Rs 509 plan that gives 1 GB per day and unlimited calls for 84 days (12 weeks).The pack is priced only Rs 50 higher than the equivalent plan by Reliance Jio, which is priced at Rs 459.Before th...
Boosted by Jio’s success, Mukesh Ambani unveils his future plans Mukesh Ambani, India's richest man, said telecom was the first of his big bet, and he will now use his resources to solve problems in three other difficult areas -- agriculture, education and healthcare.Speaking at the HT Leadership Summit, Ambani said his primary motivation...
Bharti Airtel denies violating Aadhaar norms Bharti Airtel today said it has not violated any norms set down by the UID Authority of India for the use of Aadhaar verification.Responding to a notice from the stock exchanges, the company confirmed having received notices from the UID Authority on alleged violations of no...
Will Reliance Jio launch Rs 199 plan with 1 GB per day for 28 days? A new plan being bundled with Xiaomi's new affordable plan, Redmi 5A, suggests that Reliance Jio could soon launch its first monthly unlimited plan priced at Rs 199.The plan, valid for four weeks, will give 1 GB of data per day, unlimited voice and access to Jio apps.The...
Exchanges seek clarification from Bharti Airtel on Aadhaar misuse charges Stock exchanges in India have sought a clarification from India's largest telecom company by revenue, Bharti Airtel, on a report that it was under investigation by a government agency for allegedly misusing customer data to open bank accounts in their names."(The) exchange ha...
Airtel launches VoLTE in Karnataka Bharti Airtel continued to expand its lead over Vodafone and Idea in terms of supporting 4G voice services by launching VoLTE or Voice over LTE services in Karnataka.The prices for VoLTE calls will remain identical to those of traditional calls.However, customers who us...
Tata DoCoMo users get Airtel network, but not the tariff plans yet Bharti Airtel and Tata Teleservices said they have started moving customers of Tata DoCoMo to the Bharti Airtel network using what is called an 'intra-circle roaming' or ICR agreement.This essentially means that Tata Teleservices will continue to operate a network in a techn...
Reliance Jio arrests trend of declining net additions; user activity increases Reliance Jio, India's newest operator, added 5.94 mln subscribers in September, breaking a declining trend in net additions and taking the total subscriber number to 138.62 mln (13.86 cr).Even as the company increased its subscriber numbers, it was also able to reduce the p...
Vodafone launches Aadhaar verification via vans in Rajasthan With the central government breathing down the necks of telecom operators to link all connections with Aadhaar numbers, Vodafone has launched Aadhaar verification vans in Rajasthan to ease the process.The vans were initially launched with the purpose of easing the 4G SIM upg...
Vodafone increases data on 349 plan to 1.5 GB per day Following Idea Cellular and Bharti Airtel, Vodafone too has increased the data allocation on its Rs 349 plan to 1.5 GB per day from 1 GB per day.Over the last few days, Bharti Airtel and Idea Cellular too had increased quota by 50% to cope with competition from Reliance Jio....
After Reliance Jio, Idea offers 100% cashback on Rs 357 plan Idea Cellular, reportedly India's third largest 4G operator by volume, has started offering a 100% cash-back scheme even as the Cellular Operators Association has complained against such schemes.Similar cash back schemes have been announced by Reliance Jio in an effort to ma...
As Jio reality sinks, Idea abandons ‘limited aggression’ strategy Idea Cellular has abandoned its earlier strategy of 'limited aggression' in dealing with the threat from Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel, and will be more visible in its counter strikes from now, said CEO Himanshu Kapania."From end October, Idea has shifted its earlier stand ...
Idea sees half of India remain 2G-only in 2022, to refarm 900 MHz for 4G About 600-650 mln telecom customers in India will remain 'pure 2G' users even in the year 2022, while 4G users would swell from 175 mln to 750 mln, said Himanshu Kapania, CEO of India's fourth largest telecom operator Idea Cellular.At present, India has around 1.05 bln activ...
Bharti Airtel raises Rs 3,325 cr by selling shares in Infratel Bharti Airtel said it raised Rs 3,325 crore (USD 510 Million) by selling shares in its tower subsidiary.It sold 83 mln shares at Rs 400.60 each. The price was at a discount of 3.6% to the previous day’s closing level.Shares of Infratel opened down by about 4% today due ...
Tata Teleservices loses 7.3% subscribers in October in Maharashtra Tata Teleservices, the mobile telecom arm of the Tata Group that was sold to Bharti Airtel last month, lost about 7.3% of its nearly 7 mln mobile subscribers in Maharashtra and Goa, according to a regulatory filing by the company.Tata Telservices Maharashtra Ltd, as the compa...
Idea, Vodafone to share 4G network; Broadband towers overtake 2G Idea Cellular and Vodafone in India started sharing their some of their networks in October, and will soon increase their 4G coverage by about 5,000 villages due to this, the Aditya Birla Group company said.Idea Q2 vs Q1"In October 2017, Idea and Vodafone India have ente...