HOME > BUSINESS > COMMUNICATION > Telcos Change Tack as Net Neutrality Fight Enters Final Round in India

Telcos Change Tack as Net Neutrality Fight Enters Final Round in India

A campaign by Internet Freedom Foundation

If you thought the fight over net neutrality was over with the sending of 1 mln emails to the TRAI two years ago, think again.

The telecom service providers, who lost out that in the first round, are back. This time, however, their demands are more subtle, and focused on getting specific services exempted from net neutrality regulations that are now seen as inevitable.

THE BACKGROUND

The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India had awarded the first round of the net neutrality fight in favor of the start-ups, small businesses and content creators last year.

Via its Prohibition of Discriminatory Tariffs for Data Services Regulations, it prohibited telecom companies from charging different prices for data based on end-use, forcing Bharti Airtel to roll back a plan that charged a higher price if customers used their data to make calls over WhatsApp and other apps.

UNFINISHED AGENDA

However, the 2016 regulations addressed only the pricing side of the net neutrality debate, while leaving the ‘speed up/slow down’ aspect of net neutrality for later.

Specifically, the regulation did not prevent big corporations from paying telecom companies to have traffic to their websites speeded up or to have the traffic to their rivals slowed down or blocked.

In other words, the question of neutrality in network management was left for later.

That later is now, and the topic is currently under discussion at the TRAI. Dozens of companies, organizations and individuals have given their feedback to the regulator.

As expected, there is a big difference between what telecom companies want and what the others want.

Given that the regulator indicated that it would implement anti-speedup/anti-slowdown rules, the telecom operators seemed to be focused on getting certain types of lucrative services exempted from these rules.

EXCUSE ME

The key battle lines in the second phase of the war over net neutrality is drawn on whether or not to allow telecom service providers to ‘speed up’ or ‘slow down’ certain classes of services under a ‘specialized services’ provision.

Their rationale for asking for the exemption is that many services — such as video streaming — cause ‘network congestion’, which impacts other services such as hospital data, which cannot be delayed.

So, these services should be considered ‘special’ and therefore net neutrality rules — which prevent any kind of speeding up or slowing down of traffic — should not be applicable to them, they said.

“Any service that is not a public Internet service should be considered a specialized service,” pointed out Bharti Airtel in its official response on TRAI’s net neutrality consultation, asking for exempting a clutch of services from the anti-slowdown, anti-speedup rules. “Such services include Virtual Private Networks (VPNs), enterprise solutions, Internet-based video, Internet of Things (IoT), M2M (machine to machine communication) and a whole range of innovative services for enterprises and consumers, such as remote healthcare and surgery, distance learning, and connected vehicles,” it said.

Vodafone added connected cars, smart grids, video games, live broadcast events, emergency services and “others which have specific quality of service needs” into the ‘special’ category.

IMPACT OF CARVE-OUTS

Acceptance of such suggestions could have far reaching impact on the growth of these emerging areas in India, especially since many of them already enjoy an exemption to the differential pricing rules under a closed user group provision.

If for example, the TRAI accepts Airtel’s proposal and exempts ‘Internet-based Video’ services from net neutrality requirements, that would mean that players like Netflix and Youtube would suddenly find themselves at the mercy of telecom operators who could restrict these services almost at will.

These operators could then slow down or even block these apps and push their customers to use their own offerings such as Wynk, Idea Live, JioTV, Vodafone Play etc..

Similarly, if ‘Internet of Things’ is exempted from net neutrality regulations as suggested by the telcos, private companies that provide services such as payment services using swipe machines, automatic power-meter reading, navigation and fleet services, camera-based surveillance solutions and so on could all find themselves at the operators’ mercy.

If these smaller companies are blocked, then customers will have no option but to go for similar solutions provided by telecom companies. An example of such a service is Unllimit from Reliance Communications.

On the other hand, if the TRAI refuses to exempt these services from net neutrality requirements, the telecom operators will have to fight it out with other app makers to get customers.

The demand by telcos was opposed by consumer and user rights organizations and content makers.

NASSCOM

“We believe, Net Neutrality is important for IoT solutions to succeed, and traffic from IoT solutions should not be discriminated against on a licensed network,” said Nasscom, an umbrella body of India’s software and BPO companies, while accepting that certain traffic, such as those from driverless cars and heart monitors can be ‘speeded up’ irrespective of origins.

Internet Freedom Foundation, which includes ‘SaveTheInternet’ campaign, was unwilling to make any exemptions.

It said anything sent over a limited public resource like spectrum was bound to observe the regular traffic rules and could not be allowed to overtake other traffic.

“Public resources such as spectrum and right-of-way should only be utilised for providing the public with access to open and public communication media, such as the global voice telephony network and the global Internet. The universal access services license should not permit any proprietary specialised services to be provided over public resources,” it said.

It also opposed giving exemptions to ‘enterprise plans’ from the anti-slowdown, anti-speedup rules. If the enterprises need very high quality linkage, they should opt for non-Internet methods of connectivity like leased lines, the foundation said.

“These restrictions are necessary to prevent TSPs from using “enterprise plans” and “specialized services” as loopholes to violate net neutrality rules,” it said.

TIMES GROUP

Times Internet, one of the biggest online companies in the country, said telecom operators should not be allowed to slow down, block or throttle services like Youtube and Netflix, and that net neutrality regulations must cover all services including video and Internet-of-Things.

It pointed out that if a telecom provider sells its customer 100 GB of data at 10 Mbps, it should have the capacity to deliver that 100 GB, whether the user watches a video, or surfs the web or listens to music. Blocking or slowing down a video service such as Youtube or Netflix in the name of congestion after selling such high capacity packs to customers would be unfair and unethical, it said.

“If telecom service providers are not having sufficient capability in its network or not investing/upgrading it’s network to overcome the problem of traffic congestion to meet the demand, they don’t have moral right to acquire new users,” it said.

“In such a situation, TRAI should also take note of inconvenience and hardship to end-users/ consumers, who have been paying the TSP’s for the service but not getting the quality of services and/or desired content.”

CONTROLLED INTERNET

The Times Group also warned of allowing telecom companies to prioritize their own traffic over public Internet traffic.

It pointed out that just the top three telecom operators in India control 75% of the Internet users in the country, and if they were to set up an ‘intranet’ or walled garden Internet — as TRAI has allowed them last year — it would create a huge platform with no net neutrality requirements or pricing rules at all.

This would not only hamper competition, but also allow telecom providers to play the role of content gatekeepers — deciding which newspaper people should read, which shopping site they should buy from and so on.

Under last year’s differential data rules, TRAI allowed telecom operators to set up their own mini Internets — called Closed Electronic Communication Networks — and said the telcos are free to charge whatever they want from consumers and websites for inclusion in such networks.

They could also exclude or include whoever they wanted from such networks as well.

In other words, net neutrality related safeguards don’t apply inside these ‘walled gardens’ set up by the telcos.

To make sure these proprietary networks are popular, telecom companies can push their adoption using two persuasive arguments — price and speed.

On the price front, they could make their own mini internet cheaper or even completely free for customers, while recovering the cost of running it either from the users of the open Internet or the owners of websites and apps that are ‘admitted’ into their proprietary network.

Secondly — and this is the point being agitated in the current consultation — they could reserve a large part of their bandwidth for their own network, starving the real Internet of bandwidth.

This would severely impact the quality of experience for those trying to use the regular Internet and force these users to switch to the telco’s proprietary network.

In such a situation, Youtube and Netflix may not work, but the telecom company’s own video app will work. Similarly, WhatsApp may not work, but the telecom provider’s messaging app will.

Having already exempted such private networks from differential pricing rules last year, if TRAI goes ahead and also exempts them from the speedup/slowdown rules as well, it could mean the death knell of the open Internet, Times warned.

The option preferred by Times Internet is for telecom providers to treat all traffic equally, and not give priority to their own services under the guise of closed groups or special services.

In fact, the Times Group went a step further and asked the TRAI to relook at the exemption it has already provided to telco services under last year’s differential pricing rules and put in additional safeguards. For a start, it suggested that telcos should not be allowed to repackage Internet or third-party content and serve it on their ‘intranets’.

“Consumers do not understand the difference between Internet and Intranet,” it said. “For instance, if a consumer has two apps, and one is on the ‘Internet’ and one is on the ‘CECN/Intranet’ without the consumer understanding the difference, except that one has free access and one has paid access. Therefore, CECN/Intranet will defeat the very purpose of the newly introduced Prohibition of Discriminatory Tariffs for Data Services Regulation, 2016 and Net Neutrality Principles.

“It is also pertinent to note that the CECN/ Intranet of the top 3 TSPs would hold close to 75% of the total users over the entire Internet. Given the huge number of users, if similar content and services are available over the CECN/Intranet network, a time will come when CECN/Intranet shall easily substitute and finish the Internet.

“Therefore, the CECN/Intranet platform should be allowed only to provide consumption and product related informative services like network coverage or services related to connectivity, check my balance etc.”

It urged the TRAI to make sure that either net neutrality is made applicable to such mini internets or that stricter controls be placed on intranet content.

“It is our submission that TRAI must ensure and clarify that CECN (close electronic communication networks) should not be used to create large public intranets to serve content and evade the regulations… (and) telecom service providers must not be allowed to offer third parties content on their CECNs.”

MOZILLA CORP

Mozilla Corporation also warned against allowing telecom providers to speed up certain services under the guise of ‘network management’. It warned that operators could try to use such loopholes to hamper apps that compete with their own or that of their ‘partners’.

An operator, it pointed out, could launch a video app or service that stores content at different parts of its network and then proceed to give this service a higher priority over Youtube traffic, even though both are competing services.

“If a provider has entertainment content offerings that are locally cached (stored), the provider may prioritize traffic that’s locally cached over other traffic, and claim that it is doing so for network management, while refusing to allow other service providers to cache traffic locally.

“In this case, although the provider is not facially discriminating against or in favor of any specific traffic or categories of traffic, the result is nevertheless intentionally anti-competitive and should not be permitted,” it said.

As such, it said, it was against allowing telecom providers to slow down or speed up certain categories of traffic over others.

The Internet and Mobile Association of India, which represents the interests of many app makers, said giving in to demands to exempt categories such as ‘Internet of Things’ from net neutrality regulations could have unforeseen results.

“For instance the, Internet of Things merely means devices connected through the internet. This definition is so wide that it can be construed to mean anything, therefore it is recommended unless a very specific definition can be attributed to the Internet of Things, it should come within the NN rules.”

It therefore suggested that exemptions can be given only to enterprise services — such as corporate VPN services — and emergency services.

FREE SOFTWARE MOVEMENT

The Free Software Movement of India too was in favor of allowing certain emergency and time-critical traffic to be speeded up, but it warned that the telecom providers should not be allowed to charge higher tariffs from or otherwise discriminate against companies not owned by them.

“Certain specific services may indeed be excluded from the scope of net neutrality regulation.. (but) the purpose of net neutrality regulation(should) not be defeated by overly broad definitions or interpretations of specialised services,” it said.

“Such services must be demonstrably ‘a specialised service’ requiring differentiated treatment, for specific and established reasons. That said, merely by virtue of being a specialised service, one should not be exempted from any regulatory requirements whatsoever. Certain obligations and regulation, for instance concerning offering of such services in a nondiscriminatory manner must be in place,” it added.

It also warned about exempting broad categories. “One should refrain from categorising entire (and rather nebulous concepts) such as ‘Internet of Things’ as a specialised service.

“However, services where the number of reachable end-points is limited by the nature of the terminal equipment used with such services (eg: services designed for communication with individual devices, such as e-book readers as well as machine-to-machine devices like smart meters etc.) could be outside the scope of net neutrality regulation – unless they are being used to circumvent net neutrality regulation,” the Free Software Movement of India added.

Follow ULTRA.news
Are ‘truly free’ demat and trading accounts here in India with Finvasia? Finvasia, a technology-driven online broking start-up, announced that it has rolled out what it claimed was India's first 'truly' free online demat account for investing in stocks and derivatives, including futures.There have been many 'free demat account' providers in the p...
Reliance Jio tops in user satisfaction, but call drop concerns remain Percentage of customers giving 4 or 5 starsReliance Jio users are a happier lot than customers of other services, but call drops and network availability remain key concerns, according to a survey conducted by a market research firm Velocity MR.The firm conducted a study...
Vodafone India offers unlimited downloading for 5 hours at Rs 29 Taking a leaf from new entrant Reliance Jio's playbook, Vodafone India has announced a 'truly unlimited' five-hour data pack for Rs 29.The pack, called Vodafone SuperNight, will work between 1 AM and 6 AM and is open for prepaid customers only. It will work on both 3G and 4G...
RIL stock up as Reliance Jio proves doubters wrong, avoids an April dip in subscribers Shares of Reliance Industries rose 3.5% today -- an extraordinary move for such a large company -- after it emerged that not only did the company not lose subscribers when it made the transition from free to paid services in April, it actually added a few million.The result ...
TCS to create apps on Siemen’s IoT platform MindSphere Tata Consultancy Services said it will create applications on MindSphere, the cloud-based, open IoT operating system from Siemens.TCS CEO Rajesh GopinathanIoT stands for 'Internet of Things' and refers to connectivity between two machines over the Internet, with zero h...
Grasim-Adiya Birla Nuvo merger approved, ABFSL listing soon The Aditya Birla Group said it got the approval of the Company Law Tribunal for the merger of Aditya Birla Nuvo Ltd and Grasim industries Ltd and the listing of Aditya Birla Financial Services Ltd.The approval was obtained from the Ahmedabad bench."The approved Scheme ha...
Bharti Airtel gets SEBI and stock exchange nod for Telenor acquisition Bharti Airtel said it received the approval of the Securities and Exchange Board of India, BSE and National Stock Exchange of India for its proposed merger with Telenor India. Bharti Airtel further stated that Telenor India and Airtel have today filed the joint company appli...
After Zee Entertainment, Sun TV slashes channel prices ahead of TRAI rules After Zee Entertainment, it is the turn of Sun TV to slash its channel prices with effect from Sept 1 in anticipation of the implementation of new channel pricing rules by TRAI.The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India had, three months ago, announced that media companies...
Kerala High court annuls marriage of converted Hindu girl to Muslim man The Kerala High Court has annulled the marriage of a Hindu girl who converted to Islam pointing out that she did not take permission from her parents.According to Sunni Islamic law, it is compulsory for the woman to get the permission of her wali or guardian -- usually her pa...
Times Group introduces ‘exclusive’ content online for subscribers Times Group, India's largest media group, has taken a step towards what may eventually be a paid model for online news by introducing 'exclusive' content for registered users.For now, registration and membership is free. Users can sign in using their Facebook or Google ID...
Google to train six more Indian start-ups in San Francisco Google has selected six Indian Startups for the fourth class of its 'Launchpad Accelerator' program, including RailYatri, RecipeBook and FastFilmz.In the six months program, they will undergo intensive mentoring from 20+ teams across Google and mentors from top technology...
New technology makes telecom cheaper, but hurts tower companies A technology that has been around for almost a decade is now getting deployed on a large scale by Indian telecom operators to deploy 2G, 3G and 4G networks using the same base station.A Nokia illustration on old vs new situationThis could hit the revenue and growth prosp...
The fast rise of extremist Islam in Maldives When Hussain Rasheed started talking about his son, a sob choked his voice.Hussain Rasheed (left) and Shauna Aminath (rightmost)His feeble reply wasn't even audible to the small gathering for sometime. When he regained his composure the first question he asked: Why was ...
Bharti Airtel to offer cheap 4G plans for all dongle users – report With new operator Reliance Jio snapping at its heels, incumbent Bharti Airtel has decided to slash its data prices for everyone with the introduction of new 4G dongle plans, Telecom Talk blog reported quoting unnamed sources.At present, Bharti Airtel does not offer any plan t...
Bharti Airtel slashes home broadband tariff ahead of Jio Fiber launch Ahead of the launch of Jio Fiber by Reliance, Bharti Airtel slashed its home broadband prices with a new set of cheaper plans.The new plans now offer up to 100% more high speed data benefits within the same monthly rentals, the company said. Existing customers will b...
Bharti Airtel could help Reliance Jio win Rs 2,000 cr from DoT Bharti Airtel's attempts to avoid paying "voice conversion charge" on the spectrum that it is purchasing from internet service provider Tikona Digital could end up unintentionally benefiting arch rival Reliance Jio.Reliance Jio was forced to pay around Rs 1,650 cr four ye...
Airtel, Idea and Vodafone close to network sharing deal Fierce competition from new entrant Reliance Jio is pushing the incumbent telecom operators Bharti Airtel, Reliance Jio and Vodafone India to accelerate negotiations to allow them to use each other's full networks.As of now, these operators only share 'passive' or 'dead' in...
Reliance Jio puts more 4G spectrum to use to increase speeds Reliance Jio, the 4G operator that has taken the market by storm, has deployed the extra spectrum that it bought last year, increasing the total spectrum in use in most markets by 20-25%.In most circles, Jio is operating with about 40-50 MHz of spectrum, and with the new sp...
4,196 villages lose Idea Cellular 2G signal as 876 towers taken offline Idea's tower growth, by technologyIdea Cellular, India's third largest telecom operator by revenue, reported a shrinkage in the area and population covered by its 2G network.The number of villages covered by Idea's 2G signals decreased by 4,196 to 3.89 lakh by March end ...
Bharti Airtel to start refarming 2G spectrum for 4G this year India's largest telecom services company by revenue and spectrum holding, Bharti Airtel, will start diverting its 2G spectrum to add to its 4G network in the second half of the ongoing financial year, the company's CEO said.The move will help increase 4G capacity of the o...
Idea Cellular to spend Rs 6,000 cr on VoLTE, expansion of 4G & 3G this year Idea Cellular, the telecom company controlled by the Aditya Birla group, said it will spend Rs 6,000 cr to expand its 3G and 4G services in the current financial year.Idea tower additions per yearThe planned investment of Rs 6,000 cr has been "earmarked for expanding bro...
Zee Entertainment slashes channel prices ahead of TRAI regulation Zee's new tariff card for HD channelsZee Entertainment, one of the four big broadcasting groups of India, has become the first player to bring its channel prices in line with an upcoming regulation issued by the Telecom Regulatory Authority of India.Zee's new tariff card...
Facebook restores world’s biggest page for Atheists after outcry Facebook has restored 'Atheist Republic', by far the biggest page operated by the Atheist community on any social media network, after it was shut down using 'mass reporting' by religious people.The move followed a big outcry among atheists and free-speech advocates online. ...
Airtel Broadband to upgrade users to 40 Mbps V Fiber plans to beat Reliance Jio Locations of Airtel V Fiber servicesAirtel Broadband, India's second largest wired broadband service, will upgrade nearly all its DSL customers to its new 'V Fiber' vectorization technology that offers speeds of 40 Mbps, compared to 4-8 Mbps under the traditional ADSL 2 tech...
Bharti Airtel is successfully adopting the Reliance Jio model It is not every day that a new entrant forces the established players in the market to overhaul their business models. But Reliance Jio seems to be doing just that, and rivals like Bharti Airtel are proving to be quick, if slightly unwilling, learners.In the three months from...