HOME > BUSINESS > Why Reliance JIO’s new tariff plan is BAD for Bharti Airtel, Idea & Vodafone

Why Reliance JIO’s new tariff plan is BAD for Bharti Airtel, Idea & Vodafone

Airtel’s stock performance (2002-2017)

The stock of Bharti Airtel is at a two-year high, not far from its life-highs of late 2007, but going by the latest tariffs unveiled by Reliance Jio, investors will do well to hold off on the bubbly for a while longer.

Airtel closed at Rs 461.30 on Tuesday, buoyed by two factors — the positive sentiment of the Tata Group handing over their mobile business to Bharti for close to nothing, and news that Jio will again raise its rates today (Thursday.)

The last time Airtel’s stock was in the Rs 460 territory was in August 2015, just before Mukesh Ambani, chairman of Jio, dropped a bombshell by announcing his new firm will not charge for voice.

From 460, the stock fell all the way to Rs 300. The reason for the precipitous decline was not far to seek.

Voice did, and continues to, account for the vast majority of Bharti’s revenue and profit, and if Ambani was pricing voice at effectively 10-15 paise per minute against the incumbents’ 50 paise, there was a problem.

But 2017 has been a good year for Airtel stock. Factors such as the near destruction of smaller players like Reliance Communications, Telenor, Aircel and Tata Teleservices have turned investors bullish on the company.

With RCom’s proposed merger with Aircel turning out to be a dud, the entire telecom market was there for the taking of just three players, Jio, Airtel and a combined Vodafone-Idea. The Sunil Mittal firm has always been seen as more nimble and stealthy compared to Vodafone, and a combined Idea-Vodafone entity is not expected to pose much of a competitive risk to Bharti as far as strategy is concerned.

The second factor was pricing in the market. Mukesh Ambani seemed ready to follow through on his promise of regular increase in Jio’s consumer prices to more realistic levels, having effected a steep tariff increase of about 33% in July and planning another for today.

Last year, he had promised to price his mass-oriented 1GB/day plan at about Rs 320 per month — twice the average revenue that Airtel was able to get from its average customer.

If he succeeded, it was good news for Airtel as it too could look forward to a doubling of its ARPU by bundling data with voice, and if he failed, it was also good news for the company to see a rival floundering in his ambitions.

Investors suddenly saw the stock in a new light, like waking up from a bad dream. Analysts upped their expectations.

With two days remaining for Jio to announce its second tariff hike, Goldman Sachs predicted that Ambani will raise his prices by “24%”.

“We expect Jio to raise tariffs by 24% on its most popular plan (Rs 399) in the next few days, based on the pattern of its recent price hikes. We already expect Jio to take away promotions altogether by end of FY18 and any such move in the near term would be viewed positively by investors,” it said on Tuesday, the same day when the Airtel stock hit a 2-year-high.


However, the reality of the price increase has  not been as rosy, and suggests that incumbents will need to continue to make more adjustments and cut more costs to survive.

First, the increase in prices has been only 15% or about Rs 20 per month.

Against Rs 135 per month, most Jio customers will now pay Rs 155 per month, and not Rs 168 as Goldman Sachs predicted.

The second problem is not with quantum of increase, but with the nature of it.

In all its previous price increases — in April and July — Jio was careful not to sell its new plans as ‘regular’ tariff, but as promotional offers — Summer Surprise, Dhan Dhana Dhan and so on.

It also declared up front that the discounted tariffs were available only for 84 days, and the price would triple after that. This was good news for the rivals as they could look forward to a turnaround after the 84 days.

This time, however, the new plans have been filed as regular tariff, and are valid for any number of recharges and not just for the first 84 days.

In other words, these are ‘permanent plans’ and not ‘offers’.

This is likely the result of feedback from customers about its last price hike carried out in July.

Jio has probably found that there is not much more scope for increasing prices without causing a sharp drop in uptake and usage.

For now, this seems to have given pause to the company’s scheme to raise its average billing rate to Rs 320 per month — if it indeed had such a plan in the first place and it was all not part of a strategy meant to lull competitors into a false sense of hope.


What this pause means for the incumbents is that the price upgrade cycle is over, at least for the short, and possibly for the medium, term.

Jio’s base rates have been defined —  it will offer 30 GB per month and unlimited calls for about Rs 155 per month including tax.

To compare this with incumbents’ current prices, we need to convert them to price per GB and minute.

The average consumption of voice on Jio’s network is about 626 minutes per month and an average person on a 1GB/day plan consumes about 7.8 GB of data per month.

Assuming that half of the Rs 155 per month charge is for voice and half for data, this works out to a realization of 12.5 paise per minute on the voice side and Rs 10 per GB on the data side.

These will be the short to medium term tariff that the others will have compete against. However, it doesn’t mean that they have to match it.

Incumbents offer technological compatibility with older handsets and technologies, and these customers cannot move to Jio without buying a new phone. So, they can still price their 2G voice or 3G data 50% higher and get away with it till their customers find it convenient to buy a 4G phone.

On a blended level, therefore, their voice pricing can be 30% higher than Jio’s and still be competitive, while on the data side, it can be 15%-20% higher and still give the new entrant tough competition.

Therefore, voice prices can be as high as 16.25 paise per minute, and data as high as Rs 11.50 to 12.00 per GB.

Going by recent trends, we can see that Airtel is presently charging about 20 paise per minute for voice and Rs 45 per GB for data.

This means that there would be a correction of about 20-25% in voice prices, and a correction of about 70-75% in data prices over the next six to nine months.

Voice contributes 71.5% of Airtel’s total revenue, while data contributes about 23%.

A fall of 20-25% in voice revenue and 70-75% in data revenue could shrink the company’s overall turnover by 38%.

However, such price declines has always been accompanied by a sharp increase in consumption as consumers responded to the lower tariffs. This has prevented drastic declines in revenue.

For example, over the last one year, Airtel’s voice charges fell by 34%, while average voice consumption increased by 22%.

Similarly, Airtel’s average data price fell to nearly one-fourth of what it was a year ago, while per-head consumption increased to almost three times of what it was.

As a result, overall net revenue from India fell only 12% despite the price corrections.

So, while the prices will continue to head south over the next six to nine months, chances are the company’s revenue will remain largely stable due to higher consumption and a growth in the number of consumers.

However, what will continue to erode is profitability.

The company has seen a 21% decline in its profit before depreciation (charges for wear and tear of equipment) over the last one year, and a 44% decline after depreciation to 2,523 cr per quarter.

Add to it the impact of interest costs, the company’s profit has fallen by 72% over the last one year to 923 cr from 3,261 cr a year ago.

Unless the operator is able to reduce its considerable interest costs, it could come very close to posting its first loss in over a decade in the next 6-9 months as it brings its prices in alignment with market conditions.

After this period of adjustment, its margins will improve as the impact of its ‘Project Leap’ brings down operating costs in line with that of Jio. At present, Airtel spends about thrice as much (Rs 3,935 cr per quarter) on keeping its network running as Jio (Rs 1,372 cr).

The pain, however, is likely to last for about two years for Idea and Vodafone as they are in a process of merging their operations, before margins start improving.

Follow ULTRA.news
After Reliance Jio, Idea offers 100% cashback on Rs 357 plan Idea Cellular, reportedly India's third largest 4G operator by volume, has started offering a 100% cash-back scheme even as the Cellular Operators Association has complained against such schemes.Similar cash back schemes have been announced by Reliance Jio in an effort to ma...
As Jio reality sinks, Idea abandons ‘limited aggression’ strategy Idea Cellular has abandoned its earlier strategy of 'limited aggression' in dealing with the threat from Reliance Jio and Bharti Airtel, and will be more visible in its counter strikes from now, said CEO Himanshu Kapania."From end October, Idea has shifted its earlier stand ...
Idea sees half of India remain 2G-only in 2022, to refarm 900 MHz for 4G About 600-650 mln telecom customers in India will remain 'pure 2G' users even in the year 2022, while 4G users would swell from 175 mln to 750 mln, said Himanshu Kapania, CEO of India's fourth largest telecom operator Idea Cellular.At present, India has around 1.05 bln activ...
Bharti Airtel raises Rs 3,325 cr by selling shares in Infratel Bharti Airtel said it raised Rs 3,325 crore (USD 510 Million) by selling shares in its tower subsidiary.It sold 83 mln shares at Rs 400.60 each. The price was at a discount of 3.6% to the previous day’s closing level.Shares of Infratel opened down by about 4% today due ...
Tata Teleservices loses 7.3% subscribers in October in Maharashtra Tata Teleservices, the mobile telecom arm of the Tata Group that was sold to Bharti Airtel last month, lost about 7.3% of its nearly 7 mln mobile subscribers in Maharashtra and Goa, according to a regulatory filing by the company.Tata Telservices Maharashtra Ltd, as the compa...
Idea, Vodafone to share 4G network; Broadband towers overtake 2G Idea Cellular and Vodafone in India started sharing their some of their networks in October, and will soon increase their 4G coverage by about 5,000 villages due to this, the Aditya Birla Group company said.Idea Q2 vs Q1"In October 2017, Idea and Vodafone India have ente...
Idea Cellular loss widens, ARPU down, VoLTE in early 2018 Idea Cellular reported a 19.7% year-on-year decline in its standalone revenue for the second quarter of this financial year, while net loss increased to Rs 1,176 cr from 617 cr in the preceding quarter and a net profit of 4.3 cr in the year-ago period.The revenue per subscri...
American Tower Corp buys towers of Idea and Vodafone in India for $1.2 bln Vodafone India and IdeaCellular Ltd said they agreed to sell their standalone tower businesses in India to the local unit of American Tower Corp for an aggregate enterprise value of Rs 7,850 cr (US $1.2 billion).In case the sale is completed before the merger of Vodafone Ind...
Bharti Airtel unveils new postpaid plan 499 with 20 GB data Bharti Airtel said it had introduced new 4G plans for its postpaid, or contract, customers, bringing some of the benefits that were hitherto available only to the prepaid segment.The new plan has been priced at Rs 499 plan for the postpaid segment.However, compared to pr...
Airtel Broadband users get to ‘carry over’ unused data to next cycle Bharti Airtel said its home broadband users will get to carry over all unused data benefit to the next billing cycle up to a limit of 1,000 GB."This is a first of its kind innovation in the fixed home broadband segment in India. The 'Data Rollower facility will ensure that Ai...
4G prices to stay low for a year – Airtel unveils cheap 1-yr plan If there are people who expect data prices to rise substantially in the next one year, they are probably not working at Bharti Airtel.India's biggest telecom firm by revenue has unveiled long-term recharges that allow users to lock in the current cheap prices for up to a yea...
Reliance Industries to raise Rs 5,000 cr next week via listed debentures Reliance Industries said it would raise Rs 5,000 cr from the debt market by issuing debentures on Wednesday, November 8.Jio has taken the market by stormThe debentures issued will not be convertible to equity shares and will be sold privately (private placement) without ...
Hathway Broadband starts FTTH, data use up 26% in 3 months Hathway Digital said it has started rolling out fiber-to-the-home services in congested areas, and also reported a strong increase in data use after slashing prices and increase quotas.For the three months ended September, an average consumer on Hathway Broadband increased h...
Post Bharti Airtel deal, Tata DoCoMo reaches out to worried subscribers Photo by Adithya VikramTata DoCoMo has started reaching out to customers to prevent them from leaving the network in droves, ahead of a takeover of the mobile operations by Bharti Airtel.Subscribers of Tata DoCoMo, a brand operated by Tata Teleservices, had started porti...
RCom could sell assets to Reliance Jio, go virtual – Fitch Reliance Communications could ink more spectrum selling and sharing agreements with Mukesh Ambani-controlled Reliance Jio, Fitch Ratings said, adding that the Anil Ambani company would end up as a mobile virtual operator after its ongoing restructuring.RCom promoter Anil Amb...
Bharti Airtel ARPU falls below Jio’s; but data usage zooms Bharti Airtel, India's largest telecom company by revenue, reported further erosion in its revenue and profit in September quarter compared to the previous June quarter.The company reported revenue of 21,777 cr, down 12.3% compared to a year ago and down 0.8% compared to the...
Bharti Airtel Q2 profit margin up, but ARPU falls Bharti Airtel, India's largest telecom company by revenue, reported further erosion in its revenue and profit in September quarter compared to the previous June quarter.The company reported revenue of 21,777 cr, down 12.3% compared to a year ago and down 0.8% compared to t...
BSNL to increase broadband speed to 10 Mbps from tomorrow Bharat Sanchar Nigam Ltd has increased the speed of all its broadband to 10 Mbps from 2-4 Mbps from tomorrow for all plans starting from Rs 675 per month.This price and data allocation of the plans will remain unchanged, it said.For plans below Rs 675 per month, the down...
Bharti Infratel to try to buy Vodafone & Idea stake in Indus Towers Bharti Infratel, the tower arm of Bharti Airtel, said it has decided to explore the possibility of buying out the stakes of Idea Cellular and Vodafone in rival tower company Indus.Bharti and Vodafone currently own about 42% each in Indus, while Idea holds about 11%. As a res...
Bharti Airtel offers one more 4G phone for Rs 1,349 effective price After Karbonn, Bharti Airtel has now tied up with Celkon to offer a full touchscreen 4G smartphone at an effective price of Rs 1,349 and an upfront cost of Rs 2,849.The partnership is part of Airtel’s ‘Mera Pehla Smartphone’ initiative. It had announced a similar offer in as...