HOME > BUSINESS > After Star, Sony India comes down hard on moves to curb net neutrality

After Star, Sony India comes down hard on moves to curb net neutrality

SONYAfter Star TV, Sony Pictures Networks India — which runs several popular TV channels — has raised a red flag against any move to splinter the Internet into free and paid.

“Differential pricing leads to restriction of access to information. It enables TSPs to play the role of gate-keepers to the internet where they are in a position to differentiate between data packets,” Sony India said in its submission to the TRAI.

“While they may be portrayed as means of subsidizing costs of accessing the internet, it needs to be understood that such subsidization is also a way of differentiation which can distort the equilibrium of the internet as it is enjoyed today, where everybody has unrestricted access and also has equal opportunities.”

It was responding to the TRAI’s consultation on how to take the Internet to the masses. At present, India has only around 400 mln Internet users and only around the same number of computers and smartphones.

TRAI and the government are keen to take the number higher, and the regulator asked if telecom companies should be allowed to give certain websites free after taking money from the owners of the websites.

Sony, Star, Sun TV and Zee TV are the biggest content companies in India and account for the majority of video content produced in the country. The last two are yet to respond to the authority. Another media firm, the Times of India group, has already sent its response.

All content companies who have sent responses to TRAI, including Star, have vehemently opposed any move to allow telelcom companies to charge them for carrying their content.

They argue that telecom companies are using the pretext of giving Internet to poor people to charge content makers to be on the Internet. At present, any content maker — whether an individual or a company — can share content — whether videos, pictures or text — with others by paying one telecom company for an Internet connection.

However, telecom companies want to create their own Internets using public spectrum with new rules decided by them. In the new model, not only will you have to pay the telecom company who gives you your connection, but you will most likely also have to pay all the telecom networks which have been used by anyone to view or download your content.

This is different from the current model in which the downloading charges for a video rests on the person who downloads it, not on the person who originally created it.

The telecom companies’ proposals has been opposed by content companies and rights activists on the grounds that spectrum is a public property and cannot be used as and how telecom companies like.

They also point out that making content companies to pay for users’ downloads will be harmful to the emergence of new companies as they won’t be able to afford the costs.

“While we strongly believe that there is an urgent need to connect a billion unconnected people and narrow the digital divide, we certainly believe that there are other transparent and more effective ways of achieving that goal,” Sony said.

“Allowing TSPs (telecom service providers) to charge differently for different uses of data essentially would essentially create a tariff regime where TSPs would have the right to create different classes of subscribers based on the kind of content they want to access and determine different prices for different websites, applications and platforms.

“Such differential pricing would thus allow TSPs to fundamentally alter the nature of competition between these websites, applications and platforms in a manner not linked to the quality of the services they deliver to consumers, but on the business arrangement between the TSPs and the websites, applications, platforms etc. This would also end up distorting and altering the primary role of TSPs.”

“The possibility of competition between different companies could be subverted if competitors could collude with TSPs. Such collusion would invariably result in financially able entities paying carriers to ensure that a competitor’s website loads slowly, or is inaccessible altogether, or the use to it is more cost intensive…

“It is submitted that such activities in addition to being anti-competitive and unfair, would also give rise to increasing market entry costs for non-participating entities, using dominance in the market to abuse the same through service tie ups and predatory pricing. It is therefore submitted that any such differential pricing arrangement for data services between the TSPs and websites/applications/service/content providers etc. would be violative of the provisions of the Competition Act, 2002.

“In recent times, it has been seen that a prominent telecom service provider in the country is providing access to one of the foremost social media networking sites on a zero rating plan. It is submitted that such an arrangement would have an appreciable and adverse effect on competition which does not form a part of such an arrangement. Such service tie ups and predatory pricing would ensure that there is an increase of market entry costs for non-participating entities, which incidentally did not exist when the said social media networking site itself was a start-up. It is also submitted that TRAI should also seek the opinion of the Competition Commission of India to understand the anti-competitive effects of the differential price regime,” Sony said.

The company also drew the regulator’s attention to the scenario in cable services, and warned that telecom players are trying to replicate such a model on the Internet.

“Such a differential pricing regime would also create a system which replicates the harmful effects of arrangements between carriage and content playing out in the cable and satellite space wherein MSOs instead of consumers have been prioritizing the content to be carried on their cable platforms. The basis of such prioritization being the carriage and placement fees being paid by content owners. This anticompetitive behavior by MSOs has led to small content providers being hit the most as carriage and placement fees act as entry barriers for new content providers.”

Follow ULTRA.news
Why Reliance JIO’s new tariff plan is BAD for Bharti Airtel, Idea & Vodafone Airtel's stock performance (2002-2017)The stock of Bharti Airtel is at a two-year high, not far from its life-highs of late 2007, but going by the latest tariffs unveiled by Reliance Jio, investors will do well to hold off on the bubbly for a while longer.Airtel closed a...
The Economics of Bharti Airtel’s 7777 offer on the iPhone 8 Bharti Airtel announced that it will sell high-end smartphones online with instant financing.The phones, including the iPhone 8, will be available at low downpayment and bundled monthly packages, which will make them more or less free of charge.The model was first tried ...
Bharti Airtel merges Ghana arm with Tigo of Millicom Bharti Airtel said it is merging its operations in the African nation of Ghana with the local unit of Millicom International Cellular."Under the joint agreement, Airtel and Millicom will have equal ownership (50:50) and governance rights in the combined entity, which will ha...
Reliance Jio’s New 4G Plans: No More Tariff Increases? Jio's new 4G tariff from Oct 19Reliance Jio has unveiled a set of new plans that will come into effect from tomorrow, effecting a price increase of about 15% to existing tariff.The phrasing of the new plans also suggests that these are 'regular' plans, and not promotiona...
Tata Tele acquisition good for Bharti Airtel – Fitch Bharti Airtel Limited's (BBB-/Stable) announcement that it plans to acquire the consumer mobile operations of Tata Teleservices and Tata Teleservices (Maharashtra) Ltd (Tata Telecom business) is positive for the deal participants as well as the industry, Fitch Ratings said.B...
Tata Teleservices to merge mobile business with Bharti Airtel Bharti Airtel Limited, India’s largest telecommunications services provider and Tata, India’s leading conglomerate, today announced that they have entered into an understanding to merge Consumer Mobile Businesses (CMB) of TTSL and TTML into Bharti Airtel.The move is likely ...
Reliance Jio to launch new plans on Thursday, offers 100% cashback Reliance Jio, India's most popular wireless data provider, said it will introduce new plans from Oct 19, and that it was offering "100%" cashback on its popular recharge of Rs 399 that gives three months of services.In a promotion put up on its website, the company said the ...
Airtel counters JioPhone with smartphone at Rs 1,399 net price Bharti Airtel has announced a scheme to offer a 4-inch smartphone at an effective price of Rs 1,399 -- after cash backs -- to take on the challenge posed by Reliance Jio's Jiophone.The customer needs to make a down payment of Rs 2899 for the 4G smartphone. He will get a cash...
Idea, Airtel offer 84 GB 4g data for Rs 400 to target users Airtel PlansIdea Cellular and Bharti Airtel are offering 1 GB of 3G or 4G data per day for 84 days at a price of around Rs 400 in select circles, including voice benefits, matching Jio's lowest tariff.The offer is available only for targeted users.For example, for so...
To arrest subscriber decline, Idea offers 84 GB, on-net calls for 230 rupees Idea Cellular, the third largest telecom operator in India by revenue, has started offering new customers 84 GB and free on-net calls for 84 days for just Rs 230 in the Kerala circle.Similar schemes are likely to have been launched in other circles as well.It also offers ...
Idea Cellular offers 28 GB 3G/4G data for Rs 250 Idea Cellular, which has been under pressure in recent months due to aggressive offerings from rivals Bharti Airtel and Reliance Jio, has unveiled a new promotional offer that gives 1 GB per day for 28 days at a price of around Rs 250.Unlike other plans, this one does not off...
RCom likely to shut more 2G, 3G networks, sell the spectrum Reliance Communications, which announced it was abandoning plans to merge with Aircel Cellular, indicated that it would focus on two segments - 4G and wired. Within wired, it would focus on enterprise services.The disclosure indicates that the company, -- which recently shut ...
JIO IMPACT: India mobile data usage up 500%, price down 97% in 1 year The average data consumed by wireless users in India has increased five fold in the last year one year, even as prices crashed by 97% due to the launch of Reliance Jio.For India as a whole, the total consumption of wireless data touched 4.3 bln GB in the three months from Ap...
Idea Cellular expects 7-fold increase in data consumption in one year Idea Cellular, one of India's top telecom companies, is working with the assumption that its users will increase their data consumption from the present level of around 2.2 GB per month per head to 15 GB per month by next year, CEO Himanshu Kapania said."Idea is planning on ...
Reliance Jio, Vodafone & Airtel conducting pre-5G trials – ZTE All three of India's top mobile networks -- Bharti Airtel, Vodafone and Reliance Jio -- are currently conducting trials of a key 5G technology that makes use of a very high number of antennas to increase the capacity of the network, David An, the technology head of ZTE said toda...
TRAI forcing the shut down of 2G networks – Idea Cellular CEO Idea Cellular CEO Himanshu Kapania said sector regulator TRAI was forcing telecom operators to shut down their older networks as it pushes for the adoption of newer technologies, seeking urgent intervention from the government.Kapania said the move towards phasing out of old...
Bharti Airtel dismayed, Vodafone disappointed by TRAI IUC cut As expected, incumbent telecom operators have expressed their disappointment with the regulator going ahead with cutting the interconnect charges paid by one operator to another at the time of handing off internetwork calls.The operators are likely to approach the government ...
Ambani suddenly looks like the smart guy after TRAI termination charge cut Operators such as Bharti Airtel, Vodafone, BSNL and Idea Cellular are likely to cut call tariffs for 2G and 3G users after TRAI decision to cut 'termination charges' to 6 paise per minute from 14 paise.More importantly, the bet that Mukesh Ambani placed by making voice free s...
Idea Cellular raises 4G plan prices by 25%, 84-day pack now at Rs 505 Even as Reliance Jio continues its slow move towards 'full pricing' of its services, rival Idea Cellular has taken a step towards increasing promotional 4G pack prices across its tariff cards.While the operator was offering 1GB data per day for 84 days at around Rs 400 in ke...
50% of Idea Cellular cell-sites now have 3G or 4G Idea Cellular said it has now achieved 3G or 4G penetration for 50% of its cell-sites."Idea added nearly 50,000 broadband sites over the last 12 months period ending August ’17, growing its broadband footprint to cover 5,888 Census towns and nearly 105,755 villages, reaching...