HOME > BUSINESS > Left Front tries to tap anti-American sentiment with fat tax in Kerala

Left Front tries to tap anti-American sentiment with fat tax in Kerala

leftKerala finance minister Thomas Isaac defended the new tax imposed on Western food items in Kerala even as it became clear that move could be open to a challenge on the lines on which Maharashtra’s beef ban was overturned.

The communists of Kerala — not the biggest fans of American culture — imposed the ban on select fast food items in their first budget after coming to power earlier this year.

The items on which a punitive 14.5% tax has been levied are burgers, pizzas, doughnuts, sandwiches and pasta, even if these are being served in by a roadside vendor.

The ostensible reason for the tax is that these food items tend to make people fat and are therefore unhealthy and need to be discouraged. However, the claim falls short on several grounds.

First, the consumption of the above items in Kerala is negligible and confined to the cities. They perhaps account for less than 1% of the total fat found on Malayali bodies.

Other food items, including traditional fare such as ghee rice, biriyani, fried snacks and red meat — particularly beef — contribute much more to making Malayalis fat compared to tacos and burgers — which many in the state may not have tasted even once in their lives.

Not surprisingly, charges are being leveled that the Left front is trying to impose its anti-American cultural prejudice on the whole population.

The accusation is similar to the one that the Left successfully used against the BJP in the context of the ban on beef in Maharashtra. While the beef ban was seen as the imposition of Brahmanical culture on people’s food habits, the imposition of punitive taxes on only American snacks is being seen as the imposition of Left’s anti-Americanism on the Malayali palate.

The second interpretation is more cynical. Some believe that the fat tax is a cheap political stunt to tap into the rising anti-American sentiments among certain sections of the society. A large part of Kerala society increasingly sees the US as an aggressor trying to meddle in the affairs of other countries, especially in the Middle East.

Reacting to the controversy, Finance Minister Thomas Isaac clarified that the idea of a tax on the above Western food items was suggested by Muhammad Kabeer, who used to be a teacher at Center for Development Studies, Trivandrum. He also said the tax will collect no more than Rs 10 cr in a year, and said there were no other aims for it than to discourage unhealthy food items.

It remains to be seen if someone — most probably a multinational chain like McDonalds or KFC — goes to the court to challenge the ban on grounds of discrimination.

MINISTER DEFENDS

For now, comrade Isaac is busy convincing people the move does not stem from any antipathy towards the US — a country that the Left parties in India have spend decades feelings paranoid about.

“The intention behind the move is not to mobilize funds, but to draw attention to unhealthy food habits among Keralites,” he said in a Facebook post. “The controversy generated by the move indicates that we have succeeded in this endeavor.”

On the criticism that the move spares bigger culprits such as the maida parota — a staple in the state’s restaurants — Isaac said the government was open to expanding the ambit of the ‘fat tax’ going forward.

“It is not time to impose such a tax on food items consumed by ordinary folk,” he said. “Unlike in the west, such items (as sandwiches and burgers) are consumed by well off people in Kerala (who can afford to pay more),” he added.
[socialpoll id=”2373649″]

Follow ULTRA.news
VENGARA Election Results: Left Front vote up 20%, Cong, BJP down The results of the bypoll held in Vengara assembly constituency in Kerala have confirmed the Congress-led UDF's worries about losing support in the southern state.The results also showed that the BJP suffered a decline in popularity in Kerala in the last 18 months or so....
BJP places gruesome banners of Kerala killings in New Delhi https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1669117573148867&set=pcb.1336920326413229&type=3&theater&ifg=1   In an attempt to drum up public support for its fight with the Left Front in Kerala, the BJP's Delhi unit has in the heart of the national capital place...
KERALA LOVE JIHAD: Supreme Court asks why Fadiya can’t make her own decisions The Kerala 'Love Jihad' case saw a twist today with the Supreme Court making pointed observations while hearing the appeal against a decision by the Kerala High Court to annul the marriage of a Hindu girl who converted to Islam.The court observed that it will examine the que...
NDTV officially denies sale to Ajay Singh India's oldest English television news broadcaster NDTV officially denied that it has been sold to Ajay Singh, the promoter of SpiceJet."We wish to inform you that the promoters of the Company have not entered into any agreement for sale of their stake in the Company to any ...
Stock Exchange seeks clarification from NDTV on Ajay Singh’s stake-buy NDTV Promoter Prannoy Roy with former PM Manmohan SinghThe National Stock Exchange has again sought a clarification from NDTV after the Indian Express reported that SpiceJet promoter Ajay Singh was now the biggest shareholder in the media company.UPDATE: NDTV has denied ...
CPIM activists attacked for arranging Hindu-Muslim marriage in Kerala Injured CPIM worker DileeshTensions are on the rise between the ruling CPI-M and the Social Democratic Party of India in Ambalapuzha in Kerala after Left activists were attacked, allegedly for arranging the wedding of a Muslim boy and a Hindu girl.The SDPI is second only...
Modi should decide on Khattar’s resignation, Subramanian Swamy Haryana Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar seems to be facing mounting pressure to step down, with BJP leader Subramanian Swamy hinting that the CM does not enjoy total support of BJP leaders."The question of (Khattar's) resignation has to be taken up by the prime minister, ...
Liquor shops in Kerala start installing token system Kerala's snaking long queues in front of its liquor shops -- the state's only source of alcohol after bars were banned in 2014 -- are almost as famous as the backwaters and beaches, but some relief may be on the horizon for hapless liquor buyers.As there are only about 340 li...
UPDATE: 99% of demonetized currency returned to govt Eight months on, the Reserve Bank of India is yet to finish verifying and counting the 500- and 1000-rupee notes surrendered by the public between Nov 8 and Dec 30, 2016, the finance ministry said in a statement on Aug 11.UPDATE: About ten days after this article was publishe...
Arnab Goswami’s Republic TV gets derated by Malayalis Republic TV, the channel launched by Arnab Goswami -- the former editor of Times Now -- has come in for a barrage of criticism on social media after Malayalis took offence to what has been portrayed as repeated attempts by the channel to tarnish the reputation of the state.Th...
Nawaz Sharif Proves Unlucky For The Third Time Nawaz Sharif is third time unlucky to have to abandon his term as the democratically elected Prime Minister of Pakistan.With the Supreme Court disqualifying him over the corruption cases for ten years, sixty-seven-year-old Sharif’s premiership comes to end one year before hi...
Smriti Irani Trumps PTI: Takes to twitter to expose ‘fake news’ Smriti Irani, who recently took on the role of the union minister for information and broadcasting has started off with a bang by alleging that the country's largest news wire distributed photo Chennai floods claiming them to be those of the floods in Gujarat.Unlike her prede...
Nitish, Lalu and the ‘Post Truth’ Politics of Bihar In the so-called 'post truth' politics, facts and ideology do not have a place - it is emotion and rhetoric that counts.When Nitish Kumar decided to part ways with Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) in late 2013 opposing the elevation of Narendra Modi as the prime ministerial cand...
Shiv Sena suspects Pakistan’s role behind gau-rakshaks Ratcheting up its attack on the ruling Bharatiya Janata Party, fellow saffron outfit Shiv Sena today dared cow vigilantes to fight for the country in Kashmir and asked if Pakistan was behind such attackers.India has seen two waves of vigilante attacks targeted at those who ea...
SC refuses to expedite challenge against taking back of partition migrants from Pakistan The Supreme Court has refused the request for an early listing of a petition that questions permitting descendants of people who migrated to Pakistan to come back to India.The petition seeks the quashing of the Jammu and Kashmir Rehabilitation Act of 1981 that would give the ...
‘Comrade in burqa’ divides ‘progressives’ in Kerala A photo of a young Muslim girl working with the Students Federation of India, the student wing of the Communist Party of India (Marxist), has reopened questions around whether the Left movement in Kerala is straying from its ideological roots and commitments.Ameera Khan from ...
Nestle says some products will get cheaper under GST Packaged food company Nestlé said it would pass on to consumers any reduction in tax rates due to the introduction of the goods and services tax tomorrow.Companies are not obliged to pass on the benefit of lower taxes to consumers, and many are unlikely to. The Swiss giant sa...
Pakistan Army shares video of Kashmiris celebrating cricket victory Major General Asif Ghafoor, the official spokesperson of Pakistan's armed forces, shared a video of some people in Kashmir celebrating the victory of his country's cricket team in the final of ICC Champions Trophy."And this is... Srinagar," Ghafoor said. His tweet came shortly ...
Next president be from Jammu & Kashmir — Bhim Singh Noted Kashmiri politician Bhim Singh has called on the government to appoint the next president from Jammu & Kashmir and send a strong signal to secessionists.Singh suggested the name of another Kashmiri politician Karan Singh for the post.Karan Singh is the son of the ...
The fast rise of extremist Islam in Maldives When Hussain Rasheed started talking about his son, a sob choked his voice.Hussain Rasheed (left) and Shauna Aminath (rightmost)His feeble reply wasn't even audible to the small gathering for sometime. When he regained his composure the first question he asked: Why was ...