HOME > SOCIETY > CA explains why Modi banned 1000 note & issued 2000 rupee note

CA explains why Modi banned 1000 note & issued 2000 rupee note

notesIt’s a question that has plagued the best minds of the country and no one has yet been able to figure out why the government came up with a 2,000-rupee note when it had got rid of the Rs 1000 note to control black money.

However, Mehul Shah, a chartered accountant from Surat has come up with a likely explanation for the move.

The move to come up with a 2,000 rupee note instead of a 1000-rupee note was to prevent disguising of new notes as old notes.

In other words, says Shah, if the old 1000-rupee notes were replaced by new 1000-rupee notes, it would be possible for people with undeclared income to recycle their entire holding by using just a small portion of the notes.

Imagine, says Shah, someone holding Rs 10 lakhs in bundles of 1000 rupee notes.

If the old 1000-rupee notes are replaced with a new 1000-rupee note, then all that the person has to do is take 20 old notes from the above stash, get them deposited in the bank, and then withdraw the amount on the same day.

He can do this every day and after 50 days, his entire 20 lakhs would be converted into ‘new money’.

When the Income Tax department conducts a probe, he can say that he only had 20,000 rupees with him, and he used to deposit the amount in the morning, take it out in the evening, and again deposit the same notes the next morning.

It would have been more difficult for the IT department to track that as a deposit slip does not mention the note’s serial numbers.

But he cannot do this if he got only 2,000 rupee notes when he withdrew his money on the previous day, because the next day’s deposit slip will clearly mention that he is depositing 1,000-rupee notes and not 2,000-rupee notes.

So, under the new scenario, he will go to the bank with 20 notes on day 1, and he will get only 10 notes of Rs 2,000 each. Next day, when he goes with a new bunch of 20 notes from his stash, he has to mention that he’s submitting 1000-rupee notes in the deposit slip.

Because of this, he cannot later argue that he was recycling his money every day, and that he was depositing the same 20,000 every day.

This, says Shah, is called ‘peak theory’ and is well known in the tax circles. Shah wrote all this in a letter addressed to Arvind Kejriwal.

Follow ULTRA.news
Demonetization took India forward by 3 years – SBI The demonetization of currency notes late last year has doubled the number of card transactions and helped push India's payment digitisation by three years, State Bank of India said in a note."Even after seven months post demonetization, the transaction value is quite large ...
SBI clears SB Life IPO, to sell 80 mln shares State Bank of India said it had decided to conduct an initial public offer for some of its shares in its insurance subsidiary SB Life Insurance. BNP Paribas Cardif S.A. would also sell some of its shares in the offer.It said the offer would involve 8 crore shares.No valua...
RCom says telcos facing cash flow issues due to ‘go slow’ approach by banks Telecom operator Reliance Communications said companies in the sector are facing cash flow issues due to what it called a 'go slow' approach taken by banks in disbursing loans.In an update on its 'standstill agreement' with its lenders, which provides it a window of seven mon...
Farm loan wavers can impact India’s financial profile – Fitch Ratings agency Fitch said the string of farm loan waivers announced by various Indian states could impact the financial profile of the country as a whole.The agency, however, did not directly say that the moves could lead to a downgrade in India's credit rating, which would i...
Axis Bank says 8 NPA accounts fingered by RBI owes it Rs 5,283 cr Axis Bank said eight of the 12 big defaulters highlighted by the Reserve Bank of India in its June 15 circular owed over Rs 5,000 cr to the bank.The RBI had given a list of 12 large accounts which together owed about 25% of the total bad loans of Indian banks. The total bad l...
Axis Bank confirms exiting POS maker Mswipe Axis Bank confirmed it had sold its 8% share in new-generation card-swiping-machine company Mswipe Technologies.In a regulatory filing, the private sector bank said it sold its 8% stake for Rs 80.94 cr, or Rs 4,249 per share.Mswipe is one of the new generation, low-cost ...
SBI opens QIP at floor price of Rs 287.58 State Bank of India said its committee of directors for capital raising has decided to start receiving bids a qualified institutional placement of its shares with a floor price of Rs 287.58 per equity share."The Bank may offer a discount of not more than 5% to the Floor Pric...
RCom formally assures lenders it will pay Rs 25,000 cr in four months Anil Ambani Group's telecom arm Reliance Communications said it has 'formally' communicated to its lenders that it will pay an amount of Rs 25,000 cr to them on or before Sept 30.The latest statement from the telecom operator comes as a way of reassuring investors and lenders...
Fitch cuts IDBI Bank rating as NPAs climb to 21% Fitch Ratings said it downgraded IDBI Bank's Long-Term Default Rating and its 'viability rating' by one notch each to 'BB+' and 'ccc' with a stable outlook."IDBI Bank's Viability Rating reflects the deterioration of its financial profile in the last two years and our expectat...
PAY REVISION: IDBI Bank employees to strike again tomorrow, May 23 IDBI Bank, one of India's largest government-controlled banks, said it received notice of strike from the "United Forum of IDBI Bank Officers and Employees".The strike will be on Tuesday, May 23, and is aimed at demanding "revision of pay and allowances and other issues," the...
Demonetization hits real estate builder prices, but not resale flats – report Demonetization of 500- and 1000-rupee notes hurt the real estate sector in North India, while its impact on the sector in South India was negligible, according to Magicbricks’ PropIndex for Jan-March 2017.The report, brought out by the eponymous real estate classifieds site, ...
SBI says free ATM transactions not withdrawn India's largest bank, State Bank of India, denied reports that it had scrapped the facility of providing free ATM transactions.SBI CIRCULARThe bank was responding to media reports that said that all transactions will be chargeable from now on.Under the Reserve Bank o...
There’s no Lokpal because there’s no opposition leader, says govt Lokpal act was passed after massive demonstrations in 2013The Prime Minister's office today said the government has not appointed a Lokpal at the center yet as there is no leader of the opposition in the Lok Sabha.According to the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act passed in 2013...
Rs 1.7 lakh cr deposited via demonetization may not be withdrawn – SBI Monthly cash withdrawals for all banks | source:SBI ResearchThe Indian banking system is likely to get a permanent liquidity boost of Rs 1.7 lakh cr due to the demonetization of high-denomination bank notes, State Bank of India chief economic adviser said in a note to bank c...
SBI’s new minimum balance rule leaves OBC, UCO and PSB as only ‘free’ banks in Ind... SBI Chairman Arundhati BhattacharyaWith the country's largest bank, State Bank of India, refusing to rollback service charges for customers who do not maintain a minimum balance in their accounts, only Oriental Bank of Commerce, UCO Bank and Punjab & Sind Bank remain as ...
PNB, Corp Bank most aggressive in going after big debtors; SBI, BoB more relaxed Punjab National Bank, the third largest public sector bank in India, and smaller cousin Corporation Bank can teach bigger siblings like State Bank of India and Bank of Baroda a thing or two about going after big loan defaulters, an analysis of Reserve Bank of India data shows. ...
Indian Railways ticket refunds delayed due to demonetization rush Many people who booked railway tickets worth thousands of rupees during demonetization period and cancelled these tickets for refunds are yet to get their money back.According to Indian Railway sources, many of these people could end up waiting for 90 days or more to get thei...
Yes Bank denies billion dollar QIP rumors Yes Bank, one of India's youngest, and fastest-growing banks, said it had no plans to go for a billion-dollar qualified institutional placement of its shares as reported by the media.The bank had tried to do a mega share sale in September last year, but the effort didn't find...
SBI biggest beneficiary of demonetization, HDFC Bank close behind State Bank of India and HDFC Bank were the most successful in attracting and retaining deposits in the wake of demonetization of currency, according to an analysis of their deposits growth so far this financial year.The highest growth was reported by State Bank of India, wh...
Only 50% have responded to Operation Clean Money queries A flyer for Operation Clean MoneyThe number of people who have given their responses under the government's 'Operation Clean Money' has reached 8.38 lakh as of Mar 9, slightly less than half the 17.92 lakh people to whom questions have been sent.The questions were sent i...
Bank robberies increased in J&K, Haryana after demonetization: RBI data The demonetization of high-value currency notes saw a rise in the number of bank robberies towards the end of 2016, but all of the increase came from just three states -- Jammu & Kashmir, Bihar and Haryana.Overall, cases of theft, robbery and loot of on bank properties in...
PayTM ropes in IIT Kanpur for ‘cashless campus’ PayTM, India's biggest mobile payment company and a minority subsidiary of Alibaba Group, said it partnered with Indian Institute of Technology Kanpur to bring its cashless payment solution to the country’s premier engineering college.Under the program, students will be able ...
UID says telecom operators cannot misuse Aadhaar eKYC data A schematic representation of Aadhaar eKYC provided by UIDAIThe Unique Identification Authority of India has rebutted allegations that Aadhaar data submitted by citizens to companies are prone to misuse.Aadhaar -- which is India's equivalent to the US social security num...
Arvind Kejriwal protests after Twitter cracks down on AAP accounts Aam Aadmi Party leader Arvind Kejriwal took to his account to protest the deletion of several AAP accounts after the social media company changed its anti-abuse algorithm.Three days ago, Twitter had said that it was putting in more safeguards against abuse and manipulation on...
18,420 megawatt of thermal power projects face funding difficulties in India A large chunk of under-development coal-based power units have their construction stalled due to the paucity of funds, according to numbers obtained from the power ministry.In total, projects that have a design capacity of 18,420 megawatt, or 18.42 gigawatt, are classified as...