HOME > SOCIETY > POLITICS > Preamble controversy :Are liberals losing the plot?

Preamble controversy :Are liberals losing the plot?

The popular impression is that the political right wing is dogmatic, unreasonable etc, while the left-liberals are the people who listen to logic and reason. But is it really so?

The latest ‘controversy’ over the “deleted words” from the preamble of India’s constitution forces us to rethink such notions.

For those who’ve just climbed out from under a rock, the Narendra Modi government stands accused of effacing two words -socialist and secular- from a photo of the preamble of the Indian constitution used in an advertisement.

tmp_31323-preamble-constitution-india-816572984

It is alleged that this was done as part of a right wing conspiracy to drive India away from its “secular” character. Every liberal and his aunt has already vented their frustration at this travesty of India’s constitution.

But is it really so? Did the mandarins, taking orders from the right-of-center Bharatiya Janata Party ministers, efface the two words from the photo of the preamble?

In fact, just a simple Google search would have revealed the fact of the situation – they have not.

The preamble of India, in the form of a photograph of the first page of the constitution of India, did not have these two words.

The preamble has been written down in a highly ornamental way in the original book, and the photograph of this page has traditionally been used to signify both the constitution and the preamble.

It is this widely used and symbolic photo – totally unaltered – that has been used as faded background for an advertisement taken out by the Modi government to wish citizens on the 66th Republic Day – the anniversary of the adoption of the Indian constitution.

So what could the Mandarins have done?

They could have taken the original photograph of the preamble, and digitally altered it to add the words ‘secular’ and ‘socialist’ into it, or they could have used a photo of the cover of the document.

The fact that they chose to simply use the easiest available picture can be taken as proof of their laziness, rather than of any malafide intent to dilute the secular nature of the Indian republic.

The point can be further driven home when you notice that even online Modi-baiters use the original photo and have not bothered to digitally brush the words ‘secular’ and ‘socialist’ into it (see picture).

tmp_31323-modi-895858267

Of course, this is not to say that someone sitting in the government did not get some cheap thrill from seeing the original photo put into the ad, but simply to say that this matter is getting blown out of proportion and everyone needs to take a chill pill.

Follow ULTRA.news
Ahmedabad cops deny permission to roadshow by Modi, Rahul The Ahmedabad administration has denied permission to the 'roadshows' planned by Rahul Gandhi and Prime Minister Narendra Modi in Ahmedabad tomorrow.The separate roadshows would have featured Modi and Rahul Gandhi traversing the city in a last minute effort to boost their res...
I am low-caste, but I do high work – Modi replies to Aiyer Mani Shankar Aiyar tried to undo the damage he caused to the party's prospects in Gujarat by calling Narendra Modi -- who hails from a group classified under the Other Backward Communities -- 'neech' (low or low-caste), but Modi sought to take advantage of the controversy by sei...
COLUMN: A win for Congress in Gujarat may be just what Modi needs By all accounts, the chances of a Congress victory is becoming stronger and stronger in Gujarat, a state that goes to the polls on Sunday.The possibility was almost unthinkable two months ago, even to Congress strategists, but the 'Patel factor' is likely to be the deciding ...
Uddhav Thackeray met with Sharad Pawar – report Largely along expected lines, the two warring allies within the Maharashtra government -- the BJP and the Shiv Sena -- are now reported to be wooing Sharad Pawar led Nationalist Congress Party.Shiv Sena head Uddhav Thackeray met with Pawar ten days ago, said CNN News18, and ...
“There’s no going back” says Kamal Haasan, “I’m in politics to stay... Kamal Haasan | Wikipedia Kamal Haasan today announced the launch of a new app called Mayyam or Whistle, in an attempt to organize people for a political movement, and said there was no question of turning back."If I call such a huge press meeting and I say, I am still thinki...
Kerala Love Jihad: Ashokan says he’s not anti-Muslim Akhila and Ashokan (right)Ashokan Mani, who has accused the Popular Front of India of trying to kidnap his daughter into Syria, today said he had no problems with his daughter converting to Islam or marrying a Muslim.Ashokan, who has been asked by the Supreme Court to pr...
Rahul Gandhi, Marry a Dalit girl – Ramdas Athawale Taking a jibe at Congress Vice President Rahul Gandhi's 'increasing love for Dalits', Dalit leader Ramdas Athawale said the chronic bachelor and heir to the Congress Party should now get married to a Dalit girl.Speaking at a function in Akola in Maharashtra, Athawale said Ga...
Explore autonomy for Jammu & Kashmir – P Chidambaram Former union home minister P Chidambaram today said India should 'seriously consider' giving autonomy to the state of Jammu & Kashmir.Chidambaram, who was in charge of maintaining law and order in the hill state for several years as part of his role as India's home minis...
CIA biggest beneficiary of Aadhaar, says Swamy; GST not behind slowdown BJP leader and libertarian politician Subramanian Swamy said he believes that the design of Aadhaar system exposes core data to 'American intelligence agencies' and expressed consternation that the government was continuing with the unique identification number scheme. Subraman...
Arrest warrant issued on Hardik Patel in Gujarat A non-bailable arrest warrant has been issued against Patidar Anamat Andolan Samiti leader Hardik Patel and Lalji Patel in a two-year-old case related to violence at a rally.The warrant was issued in relation to violence seen in the aftermath of a rally in Vishnagar town of ...
VENGARA Election Results: Left Front vote up 20%, Cong, BJP down The results of the bypoll held in Vengara assembly constituency in Kerala have confirmed the Congress-led UDF's worries about losing support in the southern state.The results also showed that the BJP suffered a decline in popularity in Kerala in the last 18 months or so....
BJP places gruesome banners of Kerala killings in New Delhi https://www.facebook.com/photo.php?fbid=1669117573148867&set=pcb.1336920326413229&type=3&theater&ifg=1   In an attempt to drum up public support for its fight with the Left Front in Kerala, the BJP's Delhi unit has in the heart of the national capital place...
DOKLAM 2: Why India is not sending troops to stop Chinese construction Doklam is in the news again, 40 days after the Chinese pulled back their construction equipment on the border plateau in deference to Indian sensitivities.With two weeks to go for the crucial National Congress of the Communist Party of China, India's northern neighbor has aga...
KERALA LOVE JIHAD: Supreme Court asks why Fadiya can’t make her own decisions The Kerala 'Love Jihad' case saw a twist today with the Supreme Court making pointed observations while hearing the appeal against a decision by the Kerala High Court to annul the marriage of a Hindu girl who converted to Islam.The court observed that it will examine the que...
NDTV officially denies sale to Ajay Singh India's oldest English television news broadcaster NDTV officially denied that it has been sold to Ajay Singh, the promoter of SpiceJet."We wish to inform you that the promoters of the Company have not entered into any agreement for sale of their stake in the Company to any ...
Stock Exchange seeks clarification from NDTV on Ajay Singh’s stake-buy NDTV Promoter Prannoy Roy with former PM Manmohan SinghThe National Stock Exchange has again sought a clarification from NDTV after the Indian Express reported that SpiceJet promoter Ajay Singh was now the biggest shareholder in the media company.UPDATE: NDTV has denied ...
CPIM activists attacked for arranging Hindu-Muslim marriage in Kerala Injured CPIM worker DileeshTensions are on the rise between the ruling CPI-M and the Social Democratic Party of India in Ambalapuzha in Kerala after Left activists were attacked, allegedly for arranging the wedding of a Muslim boy and a Hindu girl.The SDPI is second only...
After Doklam, Modi confirms attendance at BRICS summit, to visit Myanmar Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi will visit China to attend the upcoming conference of the BRICS forum on September 3-5, the Prime Minister's Office said today.On the way back, he will also conduct a three-day visit to Myanmar, it added."At the invitation of the Presi...
Modi’s reforms drag, power plants to face low loads, study India’s energy sector is facing low capacity utilisation in power generation as plant load factor is estimated to remain low at around 62 per cent until 2018-19, noted a recent ASSOCHAM-Crisil joint study.The study also expressed concern over the slow pace of reform implement...
Modi should decide on Khattar’s resignation, Subramanian Swamy Haryana Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar seems to be facing mounting pressure to step down, with BJP leader Subramanian Swamy hinting that the CM does not enjoy total support of BJP leaders."The question of (Khattar's) resignation has to be taken up by the prime minister, ...