HOME > SOCIETY > CRIME > Supreme Court refuses to change decision in Saumya murder case

Supreme Court refuses to change decision in Saumya murder case

Govindaswamy

The Supreme Court has dismissed a curative petition filed by the Kerala Government against its decision finding the main accused not guilty in the prominent Saumya rape and murder case of Kerala.

The case, analogous to the Nirbhaya episode of Delhi, had shocked the state.

The incident happened in 2011, when 23-year-old Soumya was travelling in a passenger train to Shoranur, returning from work in Kochi.

According to the findings of the court, the accused Govindaswamy saw the girl travelling alone in the ladies compartment and entered the bogie with an intent to rape the woman.

However, Saumya either jumped or was thrown from the train and died due to a head injury.

Govindaswamy also jumped off the train and had sexual intercourse with the girl after moving her out of the tracks. The girl was either dead or near death at the point.

Both the trial court as well as the High Court found Swamy guilty of rape and murder and awarded death sentence.

However, the Supreme Court found the accused guilty of rape, but said there was reasonable doubt about whether she had jumped from the train or whether she was thrown by Swamy.

“The court is convinced that Soumya was raped. The court also understands that she died due to head injury. However, it should be clarified whether Soumya was pushed from the train or whether she herself jumped from the train,” it said.

The SC judgement, which was delivered in September 2016 caused widespread outrage in Kerala. Many Keralites felt that it was immaterial whether the girl had jumped in fear or whether she was pushed off the train. Either way, they argued, it was caused by Govindaswamy’s attempt to rape her.

Among the vociferous critics of the judgement was former SC judge Markandeya Katju, who earned a contempt notice for his reaction.

The massive outrage over the judgement by the three judges forced the Kerala government to file a curative petition. The curative petition was heard by a six-member bench that included the original three judges — Ranjan Gogoi, Prafulla C Pant and UU Lalit — along with Chief Justice JS Khehar, Justices Dipak Misra and J Chelmeswar.

Follow ULTRA.news
Dr Reddy’s hit by class action suit on “misleading statements” on FDA action Pharma giant Dr Reddy's Labs today said that a class action lawsuit has been filed against it on behalf of shareholders, alleging that the company misled investors causing them to lose money on their investments."The lawsuit alleges that the company made materially false and...
SC refuses to expedite challenge against taking back of partition migrants from Pakistan The Supreme Court has refused the request for an early listing of a petition that questions permitting descendants of people who migrated to Pakistan to come back to India.The petition seeks the quashing of the Jammu and Kashmir Rehabilitation Act of 1981 that would give the ...
German trustee of Mumbai school sexually abuses kindergarten kids A trustee of a prominent international school in Andheri in Mumbai has been booked for sexually exploiting kids studying in kindergarten in the school.An awareness poster by Indian policeAccording to the complaint filed in MIDC police station in Mumbai, a teacher used to...
Kapil Mishra to file FIR against Arvind Kejriwal Estranged Aam Aadmi Party leader Kapil Mishra said he will file a police complaint against Arvind Kejriwal today.The rebel AAP leader has accused the party supremo of taking bribes and acting like a dictator within the party."It is with a heavy heart that I am doing this,...
Supreme Court upholds death sentence in Nirbhaya rape case The Supreme Court has upheld the death sentence for the four adults convicted in the infamous 'Nirbhaya' rape case of Delhi.A three-judge bench said the act falls 'beyond any doubt' in the 'rarest of rare' cases that is suitable for death penalty. There were two judgements be...
Supreme Court dismisses Center’s reasons for not appointing Lokpal The Supreme Court has dismissed the government of India's stand that it cannot appoint the Lokpal as there was no leader of the opposition.The court's decision came on a bunch of petitions seeking the appointment of a Lokpal is likely to lead to the first ever appointment...
All liquor shops in Tamil Nadu to remain shut for 3 months The Madras High Court has asked the government of Tamil Nadu not to open any liquor shops for three months after complaints that it did not comply with the Supreme Court order on relocating roadside liquor shops.Unlike in most states in India, alchohol shops in Tamil Nadu are...
Kerala girl secretly films man who masturbates in front of her in train A man who was looking for some cheap thrills on a train in Kerala got more than what he bargained for after the girl he was masturbating in front of secretly recorded the entire incident and uploaded it on social media.The incident is reported to have taken place on the A...
Govt likely to intensify efforts to create All India Judicial Service High Court of Karnataka, DharwadDespite setbacks and opposition from both state governments and the judiciary, the central government is not ready to give up the proposal to set up an all India service for recruitment of judges modeled on the Indian Administrative Service an...
‘Nirbhaya scheme’ for women’s transport security at standstill Road minister Nitin Gadkari demonstrating panic button (Year 2015)A well-publicized scheme for ensuring security for women in public road transport unveiled in the wake of the brutal 'Nirbhaya' rape and murder of in December 2012 seems to have ground to a halt in the absence...
Supreme Court to consider banning charge-sheeted candidates from polls The Supreme Court has today agreed to hear a petition that seeks to ban anyone who has been charge-sheeted in a criminal case from contesting elections in India.BJP leader Ashwini Upadhyay, who is among one of the most prolific filers of public interest litigation in Indi...
Nokia files more patent infringement suits against Apple Nokia has filed further complaints alleging that Apple products infringe a number of Nokia patents, expanding its litigation originally announced on December 21. Across actions in 11 countries, there are now 40 patents in suit, which cover technologies such as display, us...
Muslim Air Force men cannot grow beards – Supreme Court The Supreme Court today upheld service rules and provisions that impose 'clean shaven' rules for the Indian Air Force.Dismissing a petition by a Muslim person, the court said the Air Force was well within its authority to lay down the rule prohibiting the sporting of a beard ...
40% of High Court judge positions are vacant, 30% in trial courts A large proportion of the posts for judges in the various High Courts in India are lying vacant, resulting in painfully slow dispensation of justice, according to law ministry numbers.Out of a total of 1079 posts of judges in all the High Courts in India, a whopping 442 are l...
BCCI VS Lodha: SC says no money to be disbursed till reforms accepted The Supreme Court today asked the Board of Cricket Control in India not to disburse any money to state associations and directed state associations not to utilize any funds obtained from BCCI after its last order.If any of the state units utilize the recently disbursed fu...
Cauvery Dispute: Centre constitutes high level technical team Govt of India has constituted a high level technical team to visit the Cauvery basin area on the 7th of this month to assess the ground realities in the basin.The team will meet at Bengaluru for a preparatory meeting and subsequent visit to the Cauvery basin area for assessin...
Welspun says ‘Egyptian Cotton’ related US lawsuits not yet material Welspun said it believed that two complaints against the company for allegedly using non-Egyptian cotton may or may not be allowed to proceed as class action lawsuits, and are therefore not yet 'material'.The company was responding to a question by the stock exchanges of Indi...
Wipro says ESIC withholds dues under contract IT provider Wipro Ltd said Indian government's Employees' State Insurance Corporation has withheld payments due to it after the completion of a project, and it will take legal action to recover the amount.The seven-year contract, named Project Panchdeep, was completed on June...
ACC, Ambuja to challenge Competition Commission order ACC Ltd and Ambuja Cements said they will challenge the fine imposed by the Competition Commission of India yesterday, and that a similar order passed by the CCI four years ago had been set aside by the Competition Appellate Tribunal in December last year."We await receip...
Finance Ministry DID NOT reject Tata arbitration payment – DoCoMo Japanese telecom major DoCoMo said it was not aware of any new decision by the finance ministry on the issue of payment of arbitration amount by Tata Sons.A report by the Press Trust of India yesterday claimed that the Finance Ministry had rejected a proposal by the Reserve B...
DoCoMo reiterates Tata Sons must pay $1.17 bln DoCoMo, the Japan-based telecom group and a partner of Tata Sons in their telecom venture in India, said there are no impediments for Tata Sons to pay the penalty awarded by the London Court of International Arbitration.DoCoMo said Tata Sons should not use a recent decision b...
Patiala House rioting lawyers may lose license, Bar Council institutes probe The Bar Council of India, the top professional body for lawyers, has instituted a new enquiry into the violence in Patiala House court compound.The panel will consist of three members.If the findings are adverse, the rioting lawyers could lose their advocates' license...
Girl’s body found in drain near CM house in Lucknow The body of a student missing for five days has been found in a ditch not far from the Chief Minister's bungalow in Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh.The girl, who was studying in 12th standard in city school, had been reported missing and an FIR had been filed in Janakipuram police sta...
Supreme Court sends notice to Center on Muslim divorce laws in India The Supreme Court today sent notice to the central government in a case based on a complaint by a Muslim woman that the divorce laws applied to her in India are not in conformity with the concept of gender equality promised by the Indian constitution.The court today sought th...
Supreme Court upholds 8th pass as minimum for Panchayat elections in Haryana The Supreme Court of India has upheld the Haryana Panchayati Raj (amendment) Act 2015 that bans anyone with less than 8th standard education from standing for Panchayati Raj elections.They can, however, stand for Parliament and State Assembly elections.For general cat...