HOME > BUSINESS > Consumer courts continue to dismiss telecom complaints despite Government clarification

Consumer courts continue to dismiss telecom complaints despite Government clarification

Despite a clarification by the Department of Telecom, several consumer  disputes redressal fora in India continue to reject billing and service related disputes against telecom operators.

The Department of Telecom had issued a clarification on February 4 this year that private telecom companies cannot be identified with the “Telegraph Authority” of India as defined in the Indian Telegraph Act.

According to the Indian Telegraph Act, any dispute between the Telegraph Authority and users of telegraph facilities must be resolved outside the courts, through arbitration.

Telecom companies like Idea Cellular have successfully managed to get all billing and service related complaints against them dismissed by arguing that they are the “Telegraph Authority” of India, as their license has been issued by the Telegraph Authority. They have used a Supreme Court judgment delivered on 1-9-2009 that had dismissed a billing complaint against the Department of Telecom on similar grounds.

DoT, in its clarification, had said that just because a billing complaint against the Department of Telecom, which used to provide telephone facilities to consumers, has been dismissed under the act, telecom companies cannot seek refuge under the judgment and must be subjected to the Consumer Protection Act.

“The matter referred to in the Hon’ble Supreme Court involved a dispute between Department of Telecommunications as a service provider prior to the hiving off of telecom services into a separate company. Since DoT was also the telegraph authority, reference was made by the Hon’ble Supreme Court to the provisions of section 7B (of the Indian Telegraph Act.) However, the powers of the telegraph authority have neither been vested nor are available to private telecom services providers or BSNL. Therefore, recourse to section 7B in case of disputes between consumers and private service providers and BSNL would not be available. The Hon’ble Supreme Court’s judgment is sui generis in its application and has to be read with reference to the particular facts and circumstances of the case before it,” it had said in its clarification.

“Legal Adivsor, DoT opined that District Forums are already having jurisdiction and promulgation of ordinance (to achieve that) is apparently not required. The District Consumer Forums are competent to deal with the disputes between individual telecom consumers and telecom service providers.”

However, despite this clarifications, consumer complaints about telecom companies such as Idea Cellular Ltd, Bharti Airtel Ltd and Vodafone India continue to be rejected by various consumer fora across the country, including state-level bodies.

A month after the DoT clarification, the New Delhi consumer disputes redressal forum dismissed a billing dispute against Tata Teleservices Ltd on similar grounds.

In its order in a case filed by Harinder Prasad of Okhla, it said: “We do not enter into controversy of usage or billing charges, for which we advise complainant to (approach)Telecom Arbitrator, in terms of SC Judgement.”

Similar, on the 11th of this month, the Jharkhand State forum also dismissed a complaint against BSNL on similar grounds.

“Mr. BK Pathak, learned counsel appearing for the appellant (BSNL) produced a copy of the Judgment reported in AIR 2010 SC 90, General Manager, Telecom Vs M. Krishnan & Anr and submitted that the complaint filed by the complainant is not maintainable before Consumer Forum. We find force in the submission. Accordingly, the Judgment under appeal is dispossed off..” it said.

Follow ULTRA.news
TRAI to hear the public on net neutrality in open house this month The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India has started registrations for an open house discussion on its upcoming recommendations on net neutrality.The open house discussion will be held on Wednesday, August 30 at 9:30 AM in New Delhi. The venue has not been finalized yet, and...
RCom says telcos facing cash flow issues due to ‘go slow’ approach by banks Telecom operator Reliance Communications said companies in the sector are facing cash flow issues due to what it called a 'go slow' approach taken by banks in disbursing loans.In an update on its 'standstill agreement' with its lenders, which provides it a window of seven mon...
Maneka Gandhi clarifies: Didn’t say men don’t commit suicide Union ministry of women & child development has expressed its consternation at its minister Maneka Gandhi being painted as insensitive by the media following a rather lively interaction between the minister and citizens.Media headlines today screamed that Gandhi, who has ...
After Zee Entertainment, Sun TV slashes channel prices ahead of TRAI rules After Zee Entertainment, it is the turn of Sun TV to slash its channel prices with effect from Sept 1 in anticipation of the implementation of new channel pricing rules by TRAI.The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India had, three months ago, announced that media companies...
Kerala High court annuls marriage of converted Hindu girl to Muslim man The Kerala High Court has annulled the marriage of a Hindu girl who converted to Islam pointing out that she did not take permission from her parents.According to Sunni Islamic law, it is compulsory for the woman to get the permission of her wali or guardian -- usually her pa...
NET NEUTRALITY: Netflix says let India decide what it wants to watch Netflix, the world's biggest provider of video-on-demand services, rebuffed attempts by telecom companies to control viewership of online video and said consumers must be allowed to consume any legal content on the Internet without 'gate keeping' or interference by telecom provid...
Supreme Court dismisses Center’s reasons for not appointing Lokpal The Supreme Court has dismissed the government of India's stand that it cannot appoint the Lokpal as there was no leader of the opposition.The court's decision came on a bunch of petitions seeking the appointment of a Lokpal is likely to lead to the first ever appointment...
Net Neutrality: Vodafone wants right to manipulate Internet videos Telcos want to be able to reduce video qualityVodafone India said it would like to be given the power to manage the size of videos watched by users on its mobile network and lower it automatically "for overall quality welfare".Participating in the discussions related to ...
Telcos Change Tack as Net Neutrality Fight Enters Final Round in India A campaign by Internet Freedom FoundationIf you thought the fight over net neutrality was over with the sending of 1 mln emails to the TRAI two years ago, think again.The telecom service providers, who lost out that in the first round, are back. This time, however, their...
Complaints against telcos drop sharply as 4G takes off No of complaints against telcos in last three years. 2017 nos are annualizedComplaints against all telecom providers except Bharti Airtel dropped in 2016, possibly in reaction to the emergence of new operator Reliance Jio and the explosion of 4G data capacity.The total n...
Govt likely to intensify efforts to create All India Judicial Service High Court of Karnataka, DharwadDespite setbacks and opposition from both state governments and the judiciary, the central government is not ready to give up the proposal to set up an all India service for recruitment of judges modeled on the Indian Administrative Service an...
Reliance Jio could replace Summer Surprise with new offer after TRAI order Reliance Jio's withdrawal of its Summer Surprise Offer is unlikely to make any difference to most of its customers, and the company may even come up with a new version of the plan to comply with the ban."The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India (TRAI) has advised Jio to with...
There’s no Lokpal because there’s no opposition leader, says govt Lokpal act was passed after massive demonstrations in 2013The Prime Minister's office today said the government has not appointed a Lokpal at the center yet as there is no leader of the opposition in the Lok Sabha.According to the Lokpal and Lokayuktas Act passed in 2013...
RBI refuses to make exceptions for Tirupati temple, Rs 4 cr old notes junked The Tirumalai TempleThe Reserve Bank of India has told the management of Tirumala Tirupati temple in Andhra Pradesh that the money deposited in the temple's hundis cannot be exchanged for new notes.The move was in response to a letter by the temple management asking if i...
Can’t allow NGOs to impede India’s growth: Center to NHRC Women from the Mahan region celebrate after cancellation of coal blocks.Greenpeace helped organize protests against open coal mining in the area.The home ministry has written back to the National Human Rights Commission that non-governmental organizations cannot be allowed t...
Police Custody Deaths: Bihar safest, Maharashtra most dangerous A total of 308 people died in police custody in the three years from 2013 to 2015 -- including 75 in Maharashtra -- but not a single policeman was convicted in any case related to custody deaths in the country during those years, data from the home ministry showed.On an ove...
No plans to impose Indian constitution on Jammu & Kashmir judiciary – Govt Flag of Jammu & KashmirLaw minister Ravi Shankar Prasad today said the government of India had no plans to force judiciary in the state of Jammu & Kashmir to take their oath of office on the Indian constitution instead of the state constitution.Prasad was respond...
Reliance Jio carries 80% of traffic on next-gen Internet technology IPv6 roll-out on Jio. source:APNICReliance Jio, the new entrant to India's telecom landscape, is carrying nearly 80% of its traffic in the next-generation Internet technology, a senior official of the company said.Internet Protocol or IP is one of the languages used by machi...
Supreme Court to consider banning charge-sheeted candidates from polls The Supreme Court has today agreed to hear a petition that seeks to ban anyone who has been charge-sheeted in a criminal case from contesting elections in India.BJP leader Ashwini Upadhyay, who is among one of the most prolific filers of public interest litigation in Indi...
Govt of India starts crack down on low-quality medicine makers The government of India has started conducting inspections at drug manufacturing units across the country to prevent the production of low-quality drugs and medicines in India.Typically, inspections are conducted by state authorities, while central agencies largely confin...
There can be no Equality without Reservations – Ravi Shankar Prasad Law and Justice minister said that reservations to Dalits and backward communities was essential to ensuring equality of opportunity in government jobs.Delivering a talk on the concepts of freedom and equality in the Indian constitution, Prasad said it was wrong to think that...
No Income Tax on FCCB proceeds, SC rules on RCom The Supreme Court on Monday dismissed the petition filed by the Income-Tax Department against Reliance Communications on taxing of the proceeds of Foreign Currency Convertible Bonds (FCCBs), said the telecom operator.The Supreme Court order has quashed contingent tax liabilit...
Reliance Jio interconnect dispute with Airtel, Idea to end this month The dispute over providing interconnection facility is set to end in the next two weeks, with Bharti Airtel, Idea Cellular and Vodafone giving in to the demands of new operator Reliance Jio and the regulator.The decision to comply comes in the wake of a recommendation for a f...
Government comes up with amended anti HIV discrimination bill The government is likely to come with an amended HIV and AIDS (Prevention and Control) Bill, 2014, which was approved by the cabinet today.The HIV and AIDS Bill has been drafted to safeguard the rights of people living with HIV and affected by HIV.The provisions of the Bi...
Finally, Kerala CM takes a stand on Lawyers vs Media fight Almost three months after the tussle between various lawyers associations and journalists first hit the headlines, Kerala Chief Minister Pinarayi Vijayan today took a stand on the issue, urging lawyers to let the media do their job."The lawyers should realize that they do wro...