HOME > SOCIETY > LAW > SC dismisses Subramanian Swamy’s petition against Arun Shourie

SC dismisses Subramanian Swamy’s petition against Arun Shourie

In a significant judgment, a Supreme Court bench headed by Chief Justice of India R.M. Lodha has ruled that truth can be a valid defence in contempt of court cases, and dismissed a case filed by BJP leader Subramanian Swamy against journalist Arun Shourie.

In his petition filed in 1990, Swamy had requested contempt of court proceedings to be initiated against Arun Shourie, the then chief editor of the Indian Express newspaper for an editorial.

In the editorial, Shourie had severely criticized the findings of a commission headed by then sitting Supreme Court Judge Justice Kuldip Singh on the acts of Ramakrishna Hegde, the former Chief Minister of Karnataka.

In his editorial, Shourie said: “If there had been any sense of honour or shame, a Judge would never have done any of this. If there were any residual sense of honour or shame, the Judge having done any of it and having been found doing it, would have vacated his seat. But this is India. Of 1990, the Commissioner Kuldip Singh having perpetrated such perversities will continue to sit in judgment on the fortunes and reputations of countless citizens. He will continue to do so from nothing less than the Supreme Court of India itself. Such is our condition. And so helpless are we that there is nothing we can do about such a ‘Judge’.”

Subramanian Swamy filed a petition asking for action against Shourie.

In his petition, Swamy said “It (the editorial) lowers the authority of this Court as well as shakes public confidence in it and amounts to criminal contempt of this Court. It is submitted that unless this Court acts promptly and if necessary suo motu in the matter, sitting Judges would be helpless and unable to defend themselves, and in the process, public confidence in judges and the courts would be eroded.”

A notice was soon issued to Arun Shourie in the matter. But in 1998, the case was referred to a constitutional bench.

In its judgment delivered on 23 July, the Supreme Court bench quoted a two-judge Supreme Court judgment from 2006 in which the court had said that truth can be a defence in such cases.

The 2006 judgment by a two-judge bench had noted:

In our view, if a speech or article, editorial, etc. contains something which appears to be contemptuous and this Court or the High Court is called upon to initiate proceedings under the Act and Articles 129 and 215 of the Constitution, the truth should ordinarily be allowed as a defence unless the Court finds that it is only a camouflage to escape the consequences of deliberate or malicious attempt to scandalise the court or is an interference with the administration of justice. Since, the petitioner has not even suggested that what has been mentioned in the editorial is incorrect or that the respondent has presented a distorted version of the facts, there is no warrant for discarding the respondent’s assertion that whatever he has written is based on true facts and the sole object of writing the editorial was to enable the authorities concerned to take corrective/remedial measures.

The constitutional bench said it was in agreement with the above judgment, and truth can be a defense in such cases.

“We approve the view of the two Judge Bench in R.K. Jain. Nothing further needs to be considered with regard to second question since the amendment in contempt law has effectively rendered this question redundant,” it noted.

The court also ruled on whether or not a Judge of the Supreme Court, or any other court, carries with him all the powers of his judicial status when he is acting as a fact finding commission.

On this matter, the five-judge constitutional bench observed as follows:

“We are also in agreement with the submission of Shri Mohan Parasaran, learned Solicitor General that a Commission appointed under the 1952 Act is in the nature of a statutory Commission and merely because a Commission of Inquiry is headed by a sitting Judge of the Supreme Court, it does not become an extended arm of this Court.

“The Commission constituted under the 1952 Act is a fact finding body to enable the appropriate Government to decide as to the course of action to be followed. Such Commission is not required to adjudicate upon the rights of the parties and has no adjudicatory functions. The Government is not bound to accept its recommendations or act upon its findings.

“The mere fact that the procedure adopted by the Commission is of a legal character and it has the power to administer oath will not clothe it with the status of Court. That being so, in our view, the Commission appointed under the 1952 Act is not a Court for the purposes of Contempt of Courts Act even though it is headed by a sitting Supreme Court Judge.”

Follow ULTRA.news
Radio Jockey steps down after supporting Muslim girls for dancing Radio Jockey Sooraj of 98.6 FM, a Malayalam Radio station in Qatar, has announced that he is stepping down from his role at the station following a social media outcry over his comments supporting three Muslim girls who danced publicly at an AIDS awareness function in Kerala....
Supreme Court refuses to stay Padmavati The Supreme Court again refused to stop the movie Padmavati, urging the Central Board of Film Certification to do its job.It rejected a public interest litigation today filed by a Delhi-based lawyer."We are not going to prejudge the issue," said the court today.It poi...
Subramanian Swamy lashes out against threats to Deepika Padukone, Sanjay Leela Bhansali BJP leader Subramanian Swamy has come out strongly against right wing activists making violent threats against artists involved with the film Padmavati, saying that he could approach the courts if such threats continue."In a democracy, everyone has the right to protest, but ...
RERA sales freeze drags down DLF Q2 profit by 94%, sales restarted Real estate major DLF reported a sharp decline in its revenue and profit for the July-September quarter after it stopped taking new bookings due to the implementation of RERA in May.The company's net profit fell by 94% to Rs 12.57 cr in July-September quarter from Rs 204.60 ...
JNU students fined for cooking biryani in office after ABVP campaign The administration of the Jawaharlal Nehru University has fined its students Rs 6,000 for cooking and eating biryani in the administrative block during an overnight protest in June.The move, however, has taken a political turn as the action follows a campaign by the Akhil Bh...
Love Jihad Case: Supreme Court wants Fadiya to speak The Supreme Court today asked the government to produce Fadiya, previously known as Akhila Ashokan, before Nov 27 in the controversial 'Love Jihad' case from Kerala.In the petition filed by Fadiya's ex-husband Shafeen Jahan, the court came to the conclusion that it would nee...
Explore autonomy for Jammu & Kashmir – P Chidambaram Former union home minister P Chidambaram today said India should 'seriously consider' giving autonomy to the state of Jammu & Kashmir.Chidambaram, who was in charge of maintaining law and order in the hill state for several years as part of his role as India's home minis...
CIA biggest beneficiary of Aadhaar, says Swamy; GST not behind slowdown BJP leader and libertarian politician Subramanian Swamy said he believes that the design of Aadhaar system exposes core data to 'American intelligence agencies' and expressed consternation that the government was continuing with the unique identification number scheme. Subraman...
No decision on Sabarimala Temple Entry for women, referred to constitution bench Gender activists and others waiting for today's Supreme Court judgment on the entry of women into Kerala's Sabarimala temple were slightly disappointed today after the court refused to rule one way or the other, instead referring the matter to a constitutional bench.The benc...
NDTV officially denies sale to Ajay Singh India's oldest English television news broadcaster NDTV officially denied that it has been sold to Ajay Singh, the promoter of SpiceJet."We wish to inform you that the promoters of the Company have not entered into any agreement for sale of their stake in the Company to any ...
Stock Exchange seeks clarification from NDTV on Ajay Singh’s stake-buy NDTV Promoter Prannoy Roy with former PM Manmohan SinghThe National Stock Exchange has again sought a clarification from NDTV after the Indian Express reported that SpiceJet promoter Ajay Singh was now the biggest shareholder in the media company.UPDATE: NDTV has denied ...
India to create law to protect Indian women abroad Laws to protect Indian women who are abandoned by their NRI (non-resident Indian) husbands or foreign partners to be finalised soon, said Rakesh Srivastava, Secretary, Ministry of Women & Child Development at an ASSOCHAM event held in New Delhi today.India has taken a lead r...
NDTV stock up 76% in four days, company says no clue why Shares of New Delhi Television Ltd spiked another 10% today to Rs 62.40, prompting the BSE to write to the company to seek clarification on any undisclosed development.With this, the total gain in NDTV shares in the last four days is 76%.The company, however, said it was...
Sony loses IPL rights to Star India Star India, part of Rupert Murdoch's media empire, has won the rights to broadcast Indian Premier League matches for the next five years, edging out Sony India.The company bid Rs 16,347 cr for the privilege, edging out other groups such as Discovery. This comes to about Rs 3...
Privacy rights not above National Security – Kiren Rijiju Both individual freedom and privacy are very important but it cannot be unqualified as everything overrides when it comes to the national interest and security, Union Minister of State for Home Affairs, Kiren Rijiju said today.“When it comes to national security, I personall...
Modi should decide on Khattar’s resignation, Subramanian Swamy Haryana Chief Minister Manohar Lal Khattar seems to be facing mounting pressure to step down, with BJP leader Subramanian Swamy hinting that the CM does not enjoy total support of BJP leaders."The question of (Khattar's) resignation has to be taken up by the prime minister, ...
Islamic missionaries arrested for ‘creating tension’ between groups A group of 39 Islamic missionaries have been arrested for door-to-door distribution of religious pamphlets that said, among other things, that people who worship multiple Gods will burn in hell.The volunteers of 'Mujahid Wisdom Global Islamic Mission', who were distributing t...
Dish TV slashes HD channel price to Rs 20 from Rs 50 Dish TV, one of India's biggest DTH operators, has slashed the rates of HD and standard-definition channels to Rs 17 and Rs 8.50 each, plus a tax of 18%.Together, the cost of a single HD channel would come to around Rs 20 and that for a regular channel will come to Rs 10....
Arnab Goswami’s Republic TV gets derated by Malayalis Republic TV, the channel launched by Arnab Goswami -- the former editor of Times Now -- has come in for a barrage of criticism on social media after Malayalis took offence to what has been portrayed as repeated attempts by the channel to tarnish the reputation of the state.Th...
TRAI to hear the public on net neutrality in open house this month The Telecom Regulatory Authority of India has started registrations for an open house discussion on its upcoming recommendations on net neutrality.The open house discussion will be held on Wednesday, August 30 at 9:30 AM in New Delhi. The venue has not been finalized yet, and...